Go Back   Sonic Youth Gossip > Non-Sonic Sounds
Reload this Page when are you considered a "good" guitar player?
Register FAQ Members List Mark Forums Read

 
Thread Tools
Old 01.19.2009, 11:51 PM   #1
atsonicpark
invito al cielo
 
atsonicpark's Avatar
 
Join Date: Apr 2006
Posts: 28,843
atsonicpark kicks all y'all's assesatsonicpark kicks all y'all's assesatsonicpark kicks all y'all's assesatsonicpark kicks all y'all's assesatsonicpark kicks all y'all's assesatsonicpark kicks all y'all's assesatsonicpark kicks all y'all's assesatsonicpark kicks all y'all's assesatsonicpark kicks all y'all's assesatsonicpark kicks all y'all's assesatsonicpark kicks all y'all's asses
Maybe the better question is... When do YOU consider someone a good guitar player?

Backstory:
I have a few snobby guitarist friends who act above me, act like I don't know how to play guitar, and I'm really confused... it's really easy for me to learn songs and come up with decent riffs and I actually know a few non-power chord chords and I can tremolo pick really well, finger pick a little bit, play decent slide guitar, and can tap and do all that other extended technique bullshit pretty well. The only thing I can't do is bust out an insane shred solo. I can play some pretty technical stuff, like Beefheart and Hella stuff, yeah I'm sloppy at times but not too bad.... I've personally asked one of my snobby friends and he said everything I play sounds like Interpol (?!) and it would only sound good if it was through a million effects. Then he showed me 10 new drop-d riffs that everyone around us thought were badass. And I don't personally care if I'm considered a good guitarist, this isn't about me, it just inspired me to ask what YOU guys consider "good".
__________________




 
atsonicpark is offline   |QUOTE AND REPLY|
Old 01.20.2009, 12:02 AM   #2
Sheriff Rhys Chatham
invito al cielo
 
Sheriff Rhys Chatham's Avatar
 
Join Date: Mar 2006
Location: New England.
Posts: 4,027
Sheriff Rhys Chatham kicks all y'all's assesSheriff Rhys Chatham kicks all y'all's assesSheriff Rhys Chatham kicks all y'all's assesSheriff Rhys Chatham kicks all y'all's assesSheriff Rhys Chatham kicks all y'all's assesSheriff Rhys Chatham kicks all y'all's assesSheriff Rhys Chatham kicks all y'all's assesSheriff Rhys Chatham kicks all y'all's assesSheriff Rhys Chatham kicks all y'all's assesSheriff Rhys Chatham kicks all y'all's assesSheriff Rhys Chatham kicks all y'all's asses
Creative.
Technical skill means nothing to me.
Like dragon force, yeah they can play fast as fuck but it lacks a lot.
__________________
My Music(grunge rock)

A part of this blue shit since June 24th, 2004
Sheriff Rhys Chatham is offline   |QUOTE AND REPLY|
Old 01.20.2009, 12:03 AM   #3
acousticrock87
invito al cielo
 
acousticrock87's Avatar
 
Join Date: May 2006
Location: Los Angeles
Posts: 5,515
acousticrock87 kicks all y'all's assesacousticrock87 kicks all y'all's assesacousticrock87 kicks all y'all's assesacousticrock87 kicks all y'all's assesacousticrock87 kicks all y'all's assesacousticrock87 kicks all y'all's assesacousticrock87 kicks all y'all's assesacousticrock87 kicks all y'all's assesacousticrock87 kicks all y'all's assesacousticrock87 kicks all y'all's assesacousticrock87 kicks all y'all's asses
It's hard to say, because "good" doesn't really mean anything.

I know this might start shit, but: A lot of people consider Malmsteen to be a shitty guitarist; a lot of people consider Cobain to have been a shitty guitarist. Both opinions are, in my opinion, completely retarded. A good guitarist is a guitarist who can get up and do something with it. They don't have to have heart, and they don't have to have technical genius, but they have to have something that makes them work toward completion--of whatever goal they may be striving toward. (In the examples I gave, that would be technical proficiency and accessible aggression, respectively.)

I would consider "good" to be something bewteen humility and persistence, and I care very little what it sounds like, as long as they're going for something real.

I'm better at guitar than a lot of people I know, but I am not a good guitarist. I don't have whatever I just tried to describe. It's just a hobby for me, and I'm not very confident in it. If that makes sense.
acousticrock87 is offline   |QUOTE AND REPLY|
Old 01.20.2009, 12:09 AM   #4
pbradley
invito al cielo
 
pbradley's Avatar
 
Join Date: Apr 2007
Location: SoKo
Posts: 10,621
pbradley kicks all y'all's assespbradley kicks all y'all's assespbradley kicks all y'all's assespbradley kicks all y'all's assespbradley kicks all y'all's assespbradley kicks all y'all's assespbradley kicks all y'all's assespbradley kicks all y'all's assespbradley kicks all y'all's assespbradley kicks all y'all's assespbradley kicks all y'all's asses
Yeah, I have a friend who can solo decently but seems to refuse playing chords which is perhaps the biggest problem when jamming with him. My bass riffs were not created so that you could toss a mediocre solo over it. A lot of guitarists use technical skill as an excuse for creativity which is the exact opposite of how I approach music writing. Of course said friend hates Sonic Youth and loves the Mars Volta.
pbradley is offline   |QUOTE AND REPLY|
Old 01.20.2009, 12:18 AM   #5
RdTv
invito al cielo
 
Join Date: Mar 2006
Location: Lexington,KY USA
Posts: 2,512
RdTv kicks all y'all's assesRdTv kicks all y'all's assesRdTv kicks all y'all's assesRdTv kicks all y'all's assesRdTv kicks all y'all's assesRdTv kicks all y'all's assesRdTv kicks all y'all's assesRdTv kicks all y'all's assesRdTv kicks all y'all's assesRdTv kicks all y'all's assesRdTv kicks all y'all's asses
The land between creativity, developed skill/talent and raw expression.

The way I see it is: every instrument is like speaking. If you only use a few sentences or words to describe things, then it gets kinda boring after a while (for most listening), developing a vocabulary helps you be more creative and expressive.
RdTv is offline   |QUOTE AND REPLY|
Old 01.20.2009, 12:26 AM   #6
uhler
invito al cielo
 
uhler's Avatar
 
Join Date: Nov 2007
Location: Brooklyn
Posts: 3,615
uhler kicks all y'all's assesuhler kicks all y'all's assesuhler kicks all y'all's assesuhler kicks all y'all's assesuhler kicks all y'all's assesuhler kicks all y'all's assesuhler kicks all y'all's assesuhler kicks all y'all's assesuhler kicks all y'all's assesuhler kicks all y'all's assesuhler kicks all y'all's asses
being creative i guess. i'm not big into what's good and what's not tech wise. i'm a horrible guitar player, but a lot of the sounds i make i find to be really great.
uhler is offline   |QUOTE AND REPLY|
Old 01.20.2009, 12:27 AM   #7
This Is Not Here
invito al cielo
 
This Is Not Here's Avatar
 
Join Date: Feb 2008
Location: Kingston-Upon-Thames, London
Posts: 2,586
This Is Not Here kicks all y'all's assesThis Is Not Here kicks all y'all's assesThis Is Not Here kicks all y'all's assesThis Is Not Here kicks all y'all's assesThis Is Not Here kicks all y'all's assesThis Is Not Here kicks all y'all's assesThis Is Not Here kicks all y'all's assesThis Is Not Here kicks all y'all's assesThis Is Not Here kicks all y'all's assesThis Is Not Here kicks all y'all's assesThis Is Not Here kicks all y'all's asses
This forum has raved more than is healthy about Kevin Shields', Thurston Moore and Lee Ranaldo's guitar playing, they're creative and innovative guitarists. Yet I still don't think most guitarists would rate them as being actually 'good'. For me, the innovation accounts for everything, I just don't care whether they're objectively skilled/fast at playing guitar.
__________________
http://images.google.co.uk/url?sourc...zLTl_B146tcuiw




~~Record of the moment~~
This Is Not Here is offline   |QUOTE AND REPLY|
Old 01.20.2009, 02:00 AM   #8
GeneticKiss
expwy. to yr skull
 
GeneticKiss's Avatar
 
Join Date: Mar 2006
Location: Pittsburgh, PA
Posts: 1,666
GeneticKiss kicks all y'all's assesGeneticKiss kicks all y'all's assesGeneticKiss kicks all y'all's assesGeneticKiss kicks all y'all's assesGeneticKiss kicks all y'all's assesGeneticKiss kicks all y'all's assesGeneticKiss kicks all y'all's assesGeneticKiss kicks all y'all's assesGeneticKiss kicks all y'all's assesGeneticKiss kicks all y'all's assesGeneticKiss kicks all y'all's asses
Quote:
Originally Posted by atsonicpark
Maybe the better question is... When do YOU consider someone a good guitar player?

Backstory:
I have a few snobby guitarist friends who act above me, act like I don't know how to play guitar, and I'm really confused... it's really easy for me to learn songs and come up with decent riffs and I actually know a few non-power chord chords and I can tremolo pick really well, finger pick a little bit, play decent slide guitar, and can tap and do all that other extended technique bullshit pretty well. The only thing I can't do is bust out an insane shred solo. I can play some pretty technical stuff, like Beefheart and Hella stuff, yeah I'm sloppy at times but not too bad.... I've personally asked one of my snobby friends and he said everything I play sounds like Interpol (?!) and it would only sound good if it was through a million effects. Then he showed me 10 new drop-d riffs that everyone around us thought were badass. And I don't personally care if I'm considered a good guitarist, this isn't about me, it just inspired me to ask what YOU guys consider "good".

Unfortunately, in this age of Dragonforce and Guitar Hero Rocks The 80s, that is being seen in many quarters as the pinnacle of guitar playing.

I dunno...I don't really think I'm that good a guitarist, but I'm always having people come up to me after shows and tell me how much I rock. I guess it's because the leads, fills, and occasional solo bits I come up with seem to complement whomever I'm playing with pretty well.
__________________
https://handinthefates.bandcamp.com<--music
GeneticKiss is offline   |QUOTE AND REPLY|
Old 01.20.2009, 02:38 AM   #9
deflinus
expwy. to yr skull
 
deflinus's Avatar
 
Join Date: Jun 2006
Location: in the darkest part of your mind
Posts: 1,737
deflinus kicks all y'all's assesdeflinus kicks all y'all's assesdeflinus kicks all y'all's assesdeflinus kicks all y'all's assesdeflinus kicks all y'all's assesdeflinus kicks all y'all's assesdeflinus kicks all y'all's assesdeflinus kicks all y'all's assesdeflinus kicks all y'all's assesdeflinus kicks all y'all's assesdeflinus kicks all y'all's asses
doesn't matter whether the guitar player is playing insanely fast and technical, or if they're playing like they don't know anything - just as long as i find the sound original and innovative.. i'll say to someone "man, thats a good guitar player"
deflinus is offline   |QUOTE AND REPLY|
Old 01.20.2009, 03:21 AM   #10
Dead-Air
invito al cielo
 
Dead-Air's Avatar
 
Join Date: Dec 2006
Location: Portland OR
Posts: 4,300
Dead-Air kicks all y'all's assesDead-Air kicks all y'all's assesDead-Air kicks all y'all's assesDead-Air kicks all y'all's assesDead-Air kicks all y'all's assesDead-Air kicks all y'all's assesDead-Air kicks all y'all's assesDead-Air kicks all y'all's assesDead-Air kicks all y'all's assesDead-Air kicks all y'all's assesDead-Air kicks all y'all's asses
When the guitarist creates sounds that are aesthetically pleasing for me, then that is "good" guitar playing to me. Same with any instrument.

The old cliche is that when Lou Reed finally learned how to play guitar he made Rock 'n Roll Animal which is nowhere near as good as the Velvet Underground stuff. I have no idea how precisely true that is historically, but the essence of the point is hard to argue. The Ramones best records are certainly the first few where nobody claimed whatsoever that they knew how to play with any level of technical skill.

Doesn't mean I don't like some Eric Clapton and Kirk Hammett solos, but I also think Jandek is a good guitarist since he plays songs on the guitar that I think sound great.
Dead-Air is offline   |QUOTE AND REPLY|
Old 01.20.2009, 08:14 AM   #11
batreleaser
invito al cielo
 
Join Date: Nov 2007
Location: New York, NY
Posts: 5,155
batreleaser kicks all y'all's assesbatreleaser kicks all y'all's assesbatreleaser kicks all y'all's assesbatreleaser kicks all y'all's assesbatreleaser kicks all y'all's assesbatreleaser kicks all y'all's assesbatreleaser kicks all y'all's assesbatreleaser kicks all y'all's assesbatreleaser kicks all y'all's assesbatreleaser kicks all y'all's assesbatreleaser kicks all y'all's asses
what the fuck do i know, i just play it and see what comes.
batreleaser is offline   |QUOTE AND REPLY|
Old 01.20.2009, 08:43 AM   #12
afterthefact
invito al cielo
 
afterthefact's Avatar
 
Join Date: Jun 2006
Location: Lexington, KY
Posts: 3,886
afterthefact kicks all y'all's assesafterthefact kicks all y'all's assesafterthefact kicks all y'all's assesafterthefact kicks all y'all's assesafterthefact kicks all y'all's assesafterthefact kicks all y'all's assesafterthefact kicks all y'all's assesafterthefact kicks all y'all's assesafterthefact kicks all y'all's assesafterthefact kicks all y'all's assesafterthefact kicks all y'all's asses
It's all relative. I have friends that are all into metal, so they are not going to think I am a great guitarist. But I know that in my mind, I usually pull off what I am trying to do, at least for the moment. Skill + Creativity = Talent. There are many skilled muscians, and, guitarists especially, who forget the second part of the equation.
__________________
"She hated people who thought too much.
At that moment, she struck me as an appropriate
representative for almost all mankind." - Kurt Vonnegut Cat's Cradle
afterthefact is offline   |QUOTE AND REPLY|
Old 01.20.2009, 08:48 AM   #13
RdTv
invito al cielo
 
Join Date: Mar 2006
Location: Lexington,KY USA
Posts: 2,512
RdTv kicks all y'all's assesRdTv kicks all y'all's assesRdTv kicks all y'all's assesRdTv kicks all y'all's assesRdTv kicks all y'all's assesRdTv kicks all y'all's assesRdTv kicks all y'all's assesRdTv kicks all y'all's assesRdTv kicks all y'all's assesRdTv kicks all y'all's assesRdTv kicks all y'all's asses
Josh, good morning to you sir!
RdTv is offline   |QUOTE AND REPLY|
Old 01.20.2009, 09:15 AM   #14
demonrail666
invito al cielo
 
demonrail666's Avatar
 
Join Date: Feb 2007
Posts: 18,510
demonrail666 kicks all y'all's assesdemonrail666 kicks all y'all's assesdemonrail666 kicks all y'all's assesdemonrail666 kicks all y'all's assesdemonrail666 kicks all y'all's assesdemonrail666 kicks all y'all's assesdemonrail666 kicks all y'all's assesdemonrail666 kicks all y'all's assesdemonrail666 kicks all y'all's assesdemonrail666 kicks all y'all's assesdemonrail666 kicks all y'all's asses
Quote:
Originally Posted by Dead-Air
When the guitarist creates sounds that are aesthetically pleasing for me, then that is "good" guitar playing to me.

I think that's true to a point. Although I also think it's possible to acknowledge that someone is a 'good' guitarist even if what they do doesn't please me. (Pat Metheny, for example, is not a guitarist I like, but is, I believe, a 'better' player than, say, Julia Cafritz, who I do).

I suppose for me, a 'good' guitarist is someone with the technical ability to play a number of different styles and not have to avoid more complex ones because their skill-levels won't permit it. It's likely that Metheny could get to grips with any Pussy Galore riff fairly quickly, while it's unlikely that Cafritz could cover a Metheny tune. Which has nothing to do with whether I actually like them or not.

I say this as someone whose guitar playing makes Julia Cafritz look like Django Reinhardt.
demonrail666 is offline   |QUOTE AND REPLY|
Old 01.20.2009, 12:22 PM   #15
al shabbray
 
Posts: n/a
Quote:
Originally Posted by pbradley
Yeah, I have a friend who can solo decently but seems to refuse playing chords which is perhaps the biggest problem when jamming with him. My bass riffs were not created so that you could toss a mediocre solo over it. A lot of guitarists use technical skill as an excuse for creativity which is the exact opposite of how I approach music writing. Of course said friend hates Sonic Youth and loves the Mars Volta.

I would go with this, too.

like the ever mentioned sentence is such situations.
music is NO competition.
but a lot of guys try to make it kinda like that.
creativity far over tech skills, like in every creative environment
  |QUOTE AND REPLY|
Old 01.20.2009, 12:56 PM   #16
afterthefact
invito al cielo
 
afterthefact's Avatar
 
Join Date: Jun 2006
Location: Lexington, KY
Posts: 3,886
afterthefact kicks all y'all's assesafterthefact kicks all y'all's assesafterthefact kicks all y'all's assesafterthefact kicks all y'all's assesafterthefact kicks all y'all's assesafterthefact kicks all y'all's assesafterthefact kicks all y'all's assesafterthefact kicks all y'all's assesafterthefact kicks all y'all's assesafterthefact kicks all y'all's assesafterthefact kicks all y'all's asses
Quote:
Originally Posted by RdTv
Josh, good morning to you sir!

Indeed it is. Indeed it is.
__________________
"She hated people who thought too much.
At that moment, she struck me as an appropriate
representative for almost all mankind." - Kurt Vonnegut Cat's Cradle
afterthefact is offline   |QUOTE AND REPLY|
Old 01.20.2009, 01:29 PM   #17
Glice
invito al cielo
 
Join Date: Mar 2006
Posts: 12,664
Glice kicks all y'all's assesGlice kicks all y'all's assesGlice kicks all y'all's assesGlice kicks all y'all's assesGlice kicks all y'all's assesGlice kicks all y'all's assesGlice kicks all y'all's assesGlice kicks all y'all's assesGlice kicks all y'all's assesGlice kicks all y'all's assesGlice kicks all y'all's asses
I think it's when the sound you're making sounds like you, and not like someone else. I know quite a few shredders, and there's one who sounds like himself. He's a good guitarist. I know a few SY-ers (as it were), and there's none of them sound like themselves to me. Hardcore guitarists - I know loads, again, and only two that sound like themselves. It's less to do with their technical ability, but to do with how they forge an identity for themselves on their axe.
__________________
Message boards are the last vestige of the spent masturbator, still intent on wasting time in some neg-heroic fashion. Be damned all who sail here.

Quote:
Originally Posted by Savage Clone
Last time I was in Chicago I spent an hour in a Nazi submarine with a banjo player.
Glice is offline   |QUOTE AND REPLY|
Old 01.20.2009, 01:40 PM   #19
gualbert
the end of the ugly
 
gualbert's Avatar
 
Join Date: Oct 2007
Posts: 1,088
gualbert kicks all y'all's assesgualbert kicks all y'all's assesgualbert kicks all y'all's assesgualbert kicks all y'all's assesgualbert kicks all y'all's assesgualbert kicks all y'all's assesgualbert kicks all y'all's assesgualbert kicks all y'all's assesgualbert kicks all y'all's assesgualbert kicks all y'all's assesgualbert kicks all y'all's asses
^^
That fit with the perception of many people, that Hendrix is the best guitarist ever.
He was the first one to set his guitar on fire, not just commonly smashing it, like many others.
What a genius!
gualbert is offline   |QUOTE AND REPLY|
Old 01.20.2009, 01:43 PM   #20
SYRFox
invito al cielo
 
SYRFox's Avatar
 
Join Date: Nov 2006
Location: Paris
Posts: 7,492
SYRFox kicks all y'all's assesSYRFox kicks all y'all's assesSYRFox kicks all y'all's assesSYRFox kicks all y'all's assesSYRFox kicks all y'all's assesSYRFox kicks all y'all's assesSYRFox kicks all y'all's assesSYRFox kicks all y'all's assesSYRFox kicks all y'all's assesSYRFox kicks all y'all's assesSYRFox kicks all y'all's asses
Quote:
Originally Posted by atsonicpark
The only thing I can't do is bust out an insane shred solo.
I'm sorry, but if you can't play at least two 25 minutes Dream Theater solos, you can't consider yourself as a part of the guitar elite.
Sorry, better luck next time.
SYRFox is offline   |QUOTE AND REPLY|


Thread Tools

All content ©2006 Sonic Youth