[PAULYBEE2656]

sorry to butt in here but keira knightly isnt anorexic at all people, she is constantly fighting her corner about these things, she is just a skinny girl.... you CANT be anorexic and still keep good complexion, thats physically impossible..... she isnt an anorexic, she is just skinny, end of story and there is a huge difference between the two!

 

Originally Posted by PAULYBEE2656

you CANT be anorexic and still keep good complexion, thats physically impossible

You can have cancer and still have a good skin complexion, at least for a while before your face falls off.

[Torn Curtain]

Originally Posted by PAULYBEE2656

sorry to butt in here but keira knightly isnt anorexic at all people, she is constantly fighting her corner about these things, she is just a skinny girl.... you CANT be anorexic and still keep good complexion, thats physically impossible..... she isnt an anorexic, she is just skinny, end of story and there is a huge difference between the two!

I'm not sure if there's irony or not in your message but some anorexics have good complexion.

[pbradley]

All skinny people are anorexic or bulimic.

I win.

[Torn Curtain]

Originally Posted by pbradley

All skinny people are anorexic or bulimic.

I win.

What ?

Off course not...

[PAULYBEE2656]

Originally Posted by Torn Curtain

I'm not sure if there's irony or not in your message but some anorexics have good complexion.

how can you be anorexic and not suffer from the physical appearance of being drawn, discolouration and the obvious dehydrated look around the eyes... i mean people look like that when they get real hungry... its natural and putting your body puropsely through that isnt natural (i know anorexia aint a habit, its an illness i know, and i am not being disrespectful to sufferers like saying "go on and eat it for fuck sake" but trying to explain my point) the beautiful keira doesnt suffer outwardly, she doesnt show any dehyration marks, coke addict eyes, almost yellow complexion... so i believe her story...........

 

[Cantankerous]

in her defense she has always been very lithe and lanky
she's also very well toned and doesnt have bones sticking out in inappropriate places.

[PAULYBEE2656]

exactly my point.. so its unfair classing her as having an eating disorder........

[Cantankerous]

you can always always always tell if someone's got an eating disorder
if you're not naturally thin and you lose weight, you will have bones poking out. someone naturally very thin can be that way w/o said boniness. like twiggy.

[PAULYBEE2656]

compare if you will the last pic of ms knightley with this one of another unknown model

 

you be the judge!

Originally Posted by Cantankerous

you can always always always tell if someone's got an eating disorder
if you're not naturally thin and you lose weight, you will have bones poking out. someone naturally very thin can be that way w/o said boniness. like twiggy.

First of all an eating disorder doesn't involve just losing weight or gaining it. Second it all depends on what stage you're at in the illness itself. Third, you're both trying to diagnose someone who's generally visually manipulated for the media without standing close to them or talking to them in the flesh.

[Torn Curtain]

Originally Posted by PAULYBEE2656

exactly my point.. so its unfair classing her as having an eating disorder........

Don't get me wrong I really respect her and find her attractive, but I have personal reasons (which I don't want to elaborate on) to think she's anorexic. As I said earlier most anorexics are in denial (when they're not it's generally that they're getting out of the illness). And regarding what you said anorexia doesn't necessarily affect the body the way you described it (I guess it will be true with the most extreme cases though).

[Torn Curtain]

Originally Posted by PAULYBEE2656

 

Great pic by the way

[Cantankerous]

Originally Posted by sarramkrop

First of all an eating disorder doesn't involve just losing weight or gaining it. Second it all depends on what stage you're at in the illness itself. Third, you're both trying to diagnose someone who's generally visually manipulated for the media without standing close to them or talking to them in the flesh.

don't get me started. i was 5'6 and weighed 90 lbs when i was 14.

Originally Posted by PAULYBEE2656

compare if you will the last pic of ms knightley with this one of another unknown model

 

you be the judge!

luisel ramos
she died of anorexia. she was 5'11 and like 88 lbs.

Were you anorexic? Are you anorexic?

 

[PAULYBEE2656]

ok, im 6 foot tall. i weigh barely over 10 stone, thats heaviest ive ever been in my 33 years on this planet.... im as skinny as fuck, i eat well, probably too well and i dont put on weight or have a stomach....... and guess what.. ive never ever suffered from an eating disorder..........

[PAULYBEE2656]

Originally Posted by Cantankerous

luisel ramos
she died of anorexia. she was 5'11 and like 88 lbs.

shit, if i knew she died of this i wouldnt have posted the pic, it was just a random one i googled for.... shit! sorry......

[Cantankerous]

Originally Posted by sarramkrop

Were you anorexic? Are you anorexic?

 

was. not any more. i had a problem with binge eating aswell which is why i've lost weight (which is actually GOOD because my boobs were too heavy)

Hopefully what I'm reading is a true story, and it still it wouldn't really mean much when it comes to tell what a person suffering from eating disorder sometimes look like.

 

[demonrail666]

Originally Posted by PAULYBEE2656

ok, im 6 foot tall. i weigh barely over 10 stone, thats heaviest ive ever been in my 33 years on this planet.... im as skinny as fuck, i eat well, probably too well and i dont put on weight or have a stomach....... and guess what.. ive never ever suffered from an eating disorder..........

I used to like you Pauly, until I read that. Swine!