[Derek]

There's a difference between cutesy happy music with an asian female singer and a noise rock band with an asian female singer.

[Green Magnesium]

Originally Posted by Derek

There's a difference between cutesy happy music with an asian female singer and a noise rock band with an asian female singer.

Of course, that's why I said "1/4"!

[Piepi]

I like CocoRosie

[phoenix]

I love cocorose with all my heart. despite words in this thread. Im used to that here now.

the beats and layering and lyrics are a big reason why I like them. funny what some hate, and some like... Her voice/singing style though, is similar to a lot of girl singers whom I love so.. I put her in the same box as vocalists from lamb, catatonia, lino, portishead, even bjork a little bit..

[Torn Curtain]

I second what Savage Clone said, they played one of the worst shows I've ever seen, they were just unbearable hipsters (and I initially dug a few of their songs before so I wasn't prejudiced against them).

[Torn Curtain]

Originally Posted by Savage Clone

I'm open-minded toward music that does not contain the World's Most Irritating Vocals as its focal point, with a lame ironic hip-hop number at the end of the set.

Yes I'm still wondering what the f*** the hip-hop number number was about musically, it just seemed to be there so as to appear "décalé" and in.

[Glice]

Originally Posted by phoenix

catatonia

I maintain Cerys should never sing in English. She may be able to speak English, but I think the natural assonance of her accent doesn't lend itself to the curbed tones of English.

http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=wF87ksUUMbA
http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=TKX4m...eature=related
http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=l9H6LTX-Cgg

It's interesting how women with dynamic voices come in for more criticism than men. Or do they? I can't think of many male voices that irritate people as much as, say, Bjork does a lot of people.

[Rob Instigator]

Bjork is irritating because I get tired of her SHTICK

[Savage Clone]

Bryan Ferry bugs me as much as any squeaky-voiced female vocalist ever could.
I like "dynamic" voices just fine. Diamanda Galas has a "dynamic" voice. So do a lot of the UK folk female vocalists I adore.

What I don't like are shrill, squeaky woman-child vocals that drip with affectation.
I do not like Bjork.
I do not like Kate Bush.
I do not like Tori Amos.
I might like Deerhoof if they had a different singer.
I do not like Joanna Newsom.
I do not like CocoRosie.

However, I could name any number of male vocalists who were the dealbreaker for their particular band or music.
This is also not really a comment on how musically talented any of these people are. I think Bjork and Joanna Newsom are both incredibly talented; I just do not want to hear the sound of their voices again in my lifetime if I can avoid it, that's all.

[Rob Instigator]

mad repp

[Derek]

Originally Posted by Green Magnesium

Of course, that's why I said "1/4"!

I meant that as... of course this forum would like Deerhoof way more than any actual jpop because the music is completely different. So I don't really understand why you're bringing up Deerhoof.

And if I'm not making sense then sorry, I've not slept.

[Glice]

Originally Posted by Savage Clone

Bryan Ferry bugs me as much as any squeaky-voiced female vocalist ever could.
I like "dynamic" voices just fine. Diamanda Galas has a "dynamic" voice. So do a lot of the UK folk female vocalists I adore.

What I don't like are shrill, squeaky woman-child vocals that drip with affectation.

However, I could name any number of male vocalists who were the dealbreaker for their particular band or music.

All granted. I was more making a point about the capacity of the female voice to irritate more than a man's. I mean, I happen to think Ferry's an incredibly annoying singer, up there with Dylan/ Bowie/ all the Beatles in terms of 'voices that completely inhibit my enjoyment of the music'. Some days Reed and Sinatra annoy the hell out of me, but not always.

But the point is that if you put on, say, Harry Pussy, Sainkho Namchylak or Diamanda Galas on at the same time as the equivalent men (whose names escape me), chances are your average Joe [about whom I hate writing - terrifically vague] would hate the women's voices and just be passive to the men's.

I think Bjork and Joanna Newsom are both incredibly talented

I've said it before, and I'll say it again - the ability to play the harp is by no means the same thing as playing the harp well. She has a 'unique' (and limited) voice. Bjork, I think, has a much greater capacity as a songwriter, but I can understand her voice putting people off. Out of curiosity, what do you make of Kukl?

Bush I've no problem with; Amos is the Pumpkins for people I don't want to punch; Deerhoof are amoung the shittest things I've ever seen.

[Toilet & Bowels]

Originally Posted by Glice

But the point is that if you put on, say, Harry Pussy, Sainkho Namchylak or Diamanda Galas on at the same time as the equivalent men (whose names escape me), chances are your average Joe [about whom I hate writing - terrifically vague] would hate the women's voices and just be passive to the men's.

but then the average joe thinks music played by girls is for girls, and girls only.

[Glice]

Funnily enough, there's one Joe I know who is a total queer misogynist. And a bit of a cokehag/paeder.

Originally Posted by Glice

I maintain Cerys should never sing in English. She may be able to speak English, but I think the natural assonance of her accent doesn't lend itself to the curbed tones of English.

http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=wF87ksUUMbA
http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=TKX4m...eature=related
http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=l9H6LTX-Cgg

It's interesting how women with dynamic voices come in for more criticism than men. Or do they? I can't think of many male voices that irritate people as much as, say, Bjork does a lot of people.

It's nothing to do with the fact that they are female for me, because like it's been pointed out on this thread already, there are just as many male singers, if not more, whose voices make me want to eat rusty nails. CocoRosie aren't talented, and, to match, they have terrible voices.

I much prefer full on weird women than this pale, girly imitation of female otherness. They're on the same level as Avril Lavigne for me, attention seekers who would get frightened immediately if someone turned the lights off for real.

[Green Magnesium]

That's just it. I have no problem with "dynamic" unconventional voices as a rule. It's just a very case-by-case basis for me.

LOVE: Bjork, Bryan Ferry/Roxy Music, Diamanda Galas, Portishead, Dinosaur, Deerhoof (although I was initially put-off by Satomi's voice)

HATE: Joanna Newsom, CocoRosie, Tori Amos, Animal Collective, Will Oldham... My big problem with these artists doesn't lie solely with the vocals; their music in general gets on my nerves. The fact that they all come off as highly forced and gimmicky to me doesn't help matters.

Then again, Cerys Matthews has a voice that by rights I should find irritating, and instead I like it. I just haven't heard that many good songs she's been on.

[Glice]

Originally Posted by sarramkrop

Then again, Cerys Matthews has a voice that by rights I should find irritating, and instead I like it. I just haven't heard that many good songs she's been on.

Welsh stuff, linked above. Honestly, it's all about her in Welsh.

[pbradley]

Originally Posted by atsonicpark

I'd hit it.

 

 

PSH

 

[Rob Instigator]

the new Indigo Girls?