[iloverain4ever]

are jimi hendrix and led zeppelin considered to be shoegaze band?

[pbradley]

Yes, because they're shit.

[terriblecanyons]

You must spread some Reputation around before giving it to pbradley again.

[EyeballGrowth]

Originally Posted by swa(y)

hahaha...i love this thread (loved yr husker du one, too).

no, they arent. led zep and hendrix are better than anything in the shoegaze department.

I strongly consider that to be incorrect. I think Led Zep and Jimi Hendrix are unbelievably overrated. Jimi because he's dead and also because was the first person ever to play the electric guitar in that way. But I've heard shoegaze bands that I consider to be miles ahead of both of them. There's no point in even trying to compare them anyway

[GeneticKiss]

Oh yes, the way Jimmy Page throws his head back and holds his guitar up while he solos is very shoegaze. Same thing goes for when Jimi Hendrix humped his amps and set his guitar on fire.

[AllHandsOnTheBigOne]

more like shitgaze.

[dirty bunny]

Wind-up thread? Led Zeppelin borrowed heavily from the blues. I think some people's exposure to the blues was through Led Zep. And maybe that's why some people carry a torch for them. I liked them the first time I heard them, and they still do have a couple good songs.

Both Hendrix and Zep kinda seem a bit wanky to me anymore.

I like the stuff people label as "shoegaze" even though it's a crap label for a genre.

[finding nobody]

You gotta realize that some random journalist made this term up for music that was a product of a certain location at a certain moment in time.
While it is bullshit.. Your question is really dumb
As far as Led Zeppelin goes, I'll never get over how many songs they ripped off to like them that much but, ya know I appreatiate what they did for hard rock and yadda yadda

[pbradley]

The OP is a troll. I don't know why you all are replying to this threat seriously.

[dirty bunny]

boredom!

[noisereductions]

defining genres is a very important use of time.

[batreleaser]

anyone who says hendrix, and to a lesser extent, zeppelin, is shit needs to burn his/her entire collection of rock n roll records and just start listening to dancehall or something.

[dirty bunny]

Originally Posted by batreleaser

anyone who says hendrix, and to a lesser extent, zeppelin, is shit needs to burn his/her entire collection of rock n roll records and just start listening to dancehall or something.

I'll start with my Sonic Youth CDs.






On second though, no.

[Satan]

Originally Posted by AllHandsOnTheBigOne

more like shitgaze.

shitgaze is a completely different genre

see: wavves

http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Shitgaze

[gmku]

Originally Posted by iloverain4ever

are jimi hendrix and led zeppelin considered to be shoegaze band?

Ha ha! What!? This can't be serious.

[batreleaser]

shitgaze was a joke term made up by the psych horseshit guys that took the blogosphere .00000000002 seconds to start writing up as the new revolutionary thing.

[batreleaser]

"The term "shitgaze" was coined by Kevin De Broux of Pink Reason (and formerly of Psychedelic Horseshit) when he told Matt Whitehurst of Psychedelic Horseshit that his music wasn't like the shoegaze that Whitehurst listened to, but rather, it was "shitgaze". Whitehurst put the term on his Myspace page and it stuck[1], even growing to encompass bands from different regions that didn't have anything to do with the original scene from which the genre originated."

[Decayed Rhapsody]

Is it punk again to hate on Hendrix and Zeppelin?

Was listening to this little ditty today: http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=MkwQx7IDbTU

[Jeremy]

Speaking of this wacky "shoegaze" term, anybody around these parts hear this band called My Bloody Valentine?

~Jeremy~

[Satan]

Originally Posted by swa(y)

but...psst. fuck thurston moore anyway.

thurston is a nice guy!

oh my god iggy in that picture...i came