[RanaldoNecro]

Billy Corgan testified in front of Congress on revising the Performance Rights Act...

It seems all good to me..I don't understand why young people would think about going into music when so many others are profiting off of their work

http://blogs.suntimes.com/derogatis/...ashington.html

[phoenix]

Originally Posted by RanaldoNecro

I don't understand why young people would think about going into music when so many others are profiting off of their work

for the love of it. any creative endeavour where you set out to make a dollar before creating something of worth that is satisfying to yrself and maybe other people, is going to be disappointing for you( most of the time).

the royalties paid out to those who work in the music industry far exceed those paid to any other creative or performance artist... the avenues for receiving those royalties are set up in a far superior way to any other type of performing or visual art I can think of? Except maybe movie actors. The amount of highly paid, or even appropriately paid movie actors though I would think is much less than those who in the music biz.. Just a guess though.

[RanaldoNecro]

I just hope that the whole dynamic changes for young independent bands. Not for the Celines, SP or mega acts of the world. But for the smaller band. It is soul destroying to have someone download your music that you worked so hard on...Even more so for commercial entities to get profit off of your work

[Rob Instigator]

"don't give away what you can sell"

[Glice]

Originally Posted by phoenix

the royalties paid out to those who work in the music industry far exceed those paid to any other creative or performance artist... the avenues for receiving those royalties are set up in a far superior way to any other type of performing or visual art I can think of? Except maybe movie actors. The amount of highly paid, or even appropriately paid movie actors though I would think is much less than those who in the music biz.. Just a guess though.

Eek. At one extreme, the money is there, and there's a shitload of it. But how to get there? Run through endless fields of endless shit.

My own experience of playing live is that there's a series of entirely ridiculous economies at play. Playing functions and DJing have never failed to be lucrative for me. Playing something more creative (for which read: playing in front of ugly, poor, white people) has never been profitable. I've only ever drank more than I got paid for 'my own' gigs, although the difference is solely in the function of the music.

Right at the bottom of the creative music industry, there's loads of shit (whether inept or outright cunts) promoters, shit labels and shit bands (amoungst other shit aspects of music). At the top, there's a well-greased machine of shit. In between is mostly shit. And yet, here I am, listening to records and shit.

[joe11121]

Originally Posted by phoenix

for the love of it. any creative endeavour where you set out to make a dollar before creating something of worth that is satisfying to yrself and maybe other people, is going to be disappointing for you( most of the time).

the royalties paid out to those who work in the music industry far exceed those paid to any other creative or performance artist... the avenues for receiving those royalties are set up in a far superior way to any other type of performing or visual art I can think of? Except maybe movie actors. The amount of highly paid, or even appropriately paid movie actors though I would think is much less than those who in the music biz.. Just a guess though.

Really like this point you made.

Originally Posted by Rob Instigator

"don't give away what you can sell"

lol.

[atsonicpark]

I wish someone would put a hole in Corgan's head.

[PAULYBEE2656]

corgan couldnt even give away stuff to me let alone me buying it....

[auto-aim]

Originally Posted by Glice

Right at the bottom of the creative music industry, there's loads of shit (whether inept or outright cunts) promoters, shit labels and shit bands (amoungst other shit aspects of music). At the top, there's a well-greased machine of shit. In between is mostly shit. And yet, here I am, listening to records and shit.

Indeed, I agree... Though that "the industry" defiantly missed a trick not adapting to emerging media I think the core problem is people are caring less and less about music... Work, myspace and the media have me believe that all people give a shit about is what pointless thing is happening on Skins and some cunt called Jade Goody. Also where I'm from people are evolvong in thick necked goits... people have got to learn how to express themselves and be creative and free without some eastenders automated response. Maybe I'm closed off and a cynic. but i think if people cared and had a stake then there would be more value in it. perhaps digressing from the point... but this might always be the case