[ZEROpumpkins]

Beck - Mellow Gold

• Loser - 5/5
• Pay No Mind (Snoozer) 5/5
• Fuckin' With My Head (Mountain Dew Rock) 4/5
• Whiskeyclone, Hotel City 1997 5/5
• Soul Suckin' Jerk 3.5/5
• Truckdrivin' Neighbors Downstairs (Yellow Sweat) 4/5
• Sweet Sunshine 3/5
• Beercan 5/5
• Steal My Body Home 5/5
• Nitemare Hippy Girl 5/5
• Mutherfuker 4/5
• Blackhole 5/5

[automatic bzooty]

washing machine

becuz - 5/5
junkie's promise - 4/5
saucer-like - 5/5
washing machine - 5/5
unwind - 5/5
little trouble girl 5/5
no queen blues - 4/5
panty lies - 3/5
untitled/becuz coda - 4/5
skip tracer - 5/5
the diamond sea - 5/5

[joe11121]

Originally Posted by automatic bzooty

washing machine

becuz - 5/5
junkie's promise - 4/5
saucer-like - 5/5
washing machine - 5/5
unwind - 5/5
little trouble girl 5/5
no queen blues - 4/5
panty lies - 3/5
untitled/becuz coda - 4/5
skip tracer - 5/5
the diamond sea - 5/5

Mine..

becuz - 5/5
junkie's promise - 4/5
saucer-like - 4/5
washing machine - 4/5
unwind - 4/5
little trouble girl 4/5
no queen blues - 5/5
panty lies - 1/5
untitled/becuz coda - 5/5
skip tracer - 5/5
the diamond sea - 5/5

I think I've rated this one before on this thread but it's probably different now.

[samuel]

Becuz 3/5
Junkie's Promise 2/5
Saucer-Like 6/5
Washing Machine 5/5
Unwind 4/5
Little Trouble Girl 4/5
No Queen Blues 3/5
Panty Lies 4/5
Untitled 4/5
Skip Tracer 5/5
The Diamond Sea 4/5

[gmku]

Beastie Boys - Check Yr Head

straight 5s from start to finish

[ZEROpumpkins]

becuz - 3.5/5
junkie's promise - 3/5
saucer-like - 5/5
washing machine - 4/5
unwind - 5/5
little trouble girl 3.5/5
no queen blues - 2/5
panty lies - 1/5
untitled/becuz coda - 3/5
skip tracer - 5/5
the diamond sea - 5/5

[LifeDistortion]

Echo and the Bunnymen Ocean Rain

Silver-4
Nocturnal Me-4
Crystal Days-4
The Yo-yo Man-4
Thorn of Crowns-5
The Killing Moon-4.5
Seven Seas-4
My Kingdom-5
Ocean Rain-4
Angels and Devils-4

[Torn Curtain]

Originally Posted by joe11121

Adore:

[...]
17 - 1/5 -> an attempt at experimental music??

A tribute to that I guess (and tracks on it like "The final song"):

 

[gmku]

Radiohead - OK Computer

5s from start to finish

[joe11121]

Originally Posted by Torn Curtain

A tribute to that I guess (and tracks on it like "The final song"):

 

I actually gave the 17 second song a 1/5?? Woah. I've changed now

[automatic bzooty]

pixies - doolittle

1. Debaser - 5
2. Tame - 4.5
3. Wave of Mutilation - 5
4. I Bleed - 4.5
5. Here Comes Your Man - 5
6. Dead - 4
7. Monkey Gone to Heaven - 5
8. Mr. Grieves - 5
9. Crackity Jones - 4.5
10. La La Love You - 5
11. No. 13 Baby - 4
12. There Goes My Gun - 5
13. Hey - 5
14. Silver - 3
15. Gouge Away - 5

[canabero]

The Smashing Pumpkins - Mashed Patatoes Box Set

Disc 1

Happy Fucking Valentines N/R
Tristessa (live) 3.5
There it goes 4
Whit you 2.5
Jesus loves his babies 4.5
Stray cat blues (rolling stones) 1.5 - "i hate rolling stones"
Snail (live) 4
Bob Speaks N/R
Window Paine (live) 4.5 "good version"
Wave song 2.8
Blue (acoustic) 4
Lie I lie 2
My eternity 5
Jesus is the sun 4
Sookiie Sookie (stephenwolf) 5 "kick ass cover"

Disc 2

Slunk (live) 4
Rocket (acoustic) 3.8
Under your spell 0.7
Honeyspider 3.2
STP 4.8
Snap 2.5
Rhinocerous (live) 4.3
Let's meet the band N/R
Bleed 4
Opal 3.9
Worship 4.2
Drown (live) 4.5
Fat man blues 3.5
Trt to try 4.5
Venus in furs (Velvet underground) 4.2
WNUR Interview N/R

Disc 3

And from the west side N/R
Girl named sandoz (animals) 5
365 3.5
Spaceboy (demo) 4
The joker (steve miller) 3.5
Suffer (live) 4
Coming Attractions N/R
Egg 5
Bury me (live) 4.5
Moleasskiss 4
I am my end 5
My dahlia 3
Vanilla 5
East 3
Kill your parents N/R
Terrapin (syd barret) 2.5
Cinder 1
Luna (acoustic) 4

Disc 4

Interview Nozems a go-go N/R
Morning jam 3,5
I'm Free (the who) 4.5
Jennifer ener 4.5
Plume (live)4.3
Disarm (live) 4.5 "not a good version"
Siva (live) 4.5
Translucent 4
Not worth asking 4.7
Over you 3.7
Where's vince 5 "great song"
Smiley 5
Geek U.S.A. (Live) 4.5
Crush (live) 4
C'mon 4.5

Disc 5

Hello Kitty Kat (demo) 5 "the real good version"
Nothing and Everything 5 "one of the best songs of the band"
Mayonaise (acoustic) 5
Out of focus (blue cheer) 5
Offer up 5
Silverfuck (live) 5
Rudolph the red nosed reindeer (traditional) 4.5
Stars fall in 1.5
Godzilla (blue öyster cult) 5 "best cover ever"
Bye june (live) 3
Spiteface 5
Daydream 3.5
I'll never change 3
Infinite sadness 4.5

[ZEROpumpkins]

My doolittle:
1. Debaser - 5
2. Tame - 4.5
3. Wave of Mutilation - 5
4. I Bleed - 5
5. Here Comes Your Man - 4
6. Dead - 4
7. Monkey Gone to Heaven - 5
8. Mr. Grieves - 4
9. Crackity Jones - 4
10. La La Love You - 4.5
11. No. 13 Baby - 4
12. There Goes My Gun - 4.5
13. Hey - 5
14. Silver - 3
15. Gouge Away - 5

[Torn Curtain]

Jeff Buckley - Mystery white boy:

1. Dream Brother - 5 (maybe his best version ever)
2. I Woke Up in a Strange Place - 5
3. Mojo Pin - 5
4. Lilac Wine - 4 (not his best version)
5. What Will You Say - 4
6. Last Goodbye - 5
7. Eternal Life - 4.5
8. Grace - 5 (the guitar is too low in the mix though)
9. Moodswing Whiskey - 5
10. The Man That Got Away - 2.5
11. Kanga Roo - 5 (one of his very best versions)
12. Hallelujah/I Know It's Over (Medley) - 5 (good but I prefer other versions, Roskilde especially)

CD 2 :

1. All that I ask - 4.5
2. Lover, you should've come over - 5
3. So real - 5

[MARKJONES]

For now, I just feel like doing two albums.

Sonic Nurse:

Pattern Recognition - 4.5
Unmade Bed - 4
Dripping Dream - 5
Mariah Carey and the Arthur Doyle Hand Cream - 5 (a very underrated song)
Stones - 6
Dude Ranch Nurse - 4
New Hampshire - 3.5
Paper Cup Exit - 3.5
I Love You Golden Blue - 4
Peace Attack - 5


Rather Ripped (a fairly decent album, actually):

Reena - 4.5
Incinerate - 4.5
Do You Believe in Rapture? - 5 (i love the angelic sound of those guitar chords)
Sleepin' Around - 3.5 (the noise part saves it)
What a Waste - 3
Jams Run Free - 5
Rats - 4.5 (almost a 5, but not quite)
Turquoise Boy - 3
Lights Out - 4
The Neutral - 4
Pink Steam - 5
Or - 3.5

[joe11121]

Haha. I'll do Nurse, Rather Ripped + The Eternal (although I think I've done all before..)

Sonic Nurse:
Pattern Recognition - 5
Unmade Bed - 5
Dripping Dream - 4
Mariah Carey and the Arthur Doyle Hand Cream - 3
Stones - 5
Dude Ranch Nurse - 5
New Hampshire - 4
Paper Cup Exit - 5
I Love You Golden Blue - 5
Peace Attack - 4

Rather Ripped:
Reena - 5
Incinerate - 5
Do You Believe in Rapture? - 1
Sleepin' Around - 0
What a Waste - 3
Jams Run Free - 5
Rats - 3
Turquoise Boy - 3.5
Lights Out - 2
The Neutral - 2
Pink Steam - 5
Or - 3.5

The Eternal:
Sacred Trickster - 5
Anti-Orgasm - 5
Leaky Lifeboat - 4.5
Antenna - 5
What We Know - 4.5
Calming The Snake - 3.5
Poison Arrow - 5
Malibu Gas Station - 5
Thunderclap - 4
No Way - 3.5
Walkin Blue - 5
Massage The History - 5

[GeneticKiss]

Man, why so much hate on Sleepin' Around? It's much better live, but still, the album version isn't all THAT bad...

Reena-3.5
Incinerate-3.5
Do You Believe In Rapture?-3
Sleepin' Around-3
What a Waste-4
Jams Run Free-4
Rats-5
Turquoise Boy-5
Lights Out-2.5
The Neutral-3
Pink Steam-5
Or-4.5

I think the biggest problem with that album is the production. Very muffled, muddy, and the whole thing just seems like it never gets off the ground.