Sonic Youth Gossip

Sonic Youth Gossip (http://www.sonicyouth.com/gossip/index.php)
-   Non-Sonic Sounds (http://www.sonicyouth.com/gossip/forumdisplay.php?f=4)
-   -   I'm kinda sick of major label bands being branded as Indie rock... (http://www.sonicyouth.com/gossip/showthread.php?t=15302)

ZEROpumpkins 08.05.2007 06:55 AM

I'm kinda sick of major label bands being branded as Indie rock...
 
Intentional or not, it bugs me that it is a complete contradiction of terms. I'm afraid that it could be the next term that the media catches onto if they haven't already (like in the 90's when grunge was used to describe everything). Who else feels like this?

demonrail666 08.05.2007 07:26 AM

'Indie' has referred to a style rather than a record company's industry status for a long time now. But I agree, it is a bit annoying.

SynthethicalY 08.05.2007 01:05 PM

Eh, never bothered with anything indie, I just got into what I like. But I do see your point it is quite lame, that there are these bands that are just pop, and are called indie.

jico. 08.05.2007 01:21 PM

its in your title, it's called BRANDING

matt74m 08.05.2007 05:42 PM

I agree, but the major labels caught on to this years ago, buying indie labels so they could put stuff out that had 'credability' or whatever they want to call it.

The one that winds me up is 'alternative', which by its nature should be something different to the main stream, but again its just used to give crap bands credibility.

Think Synth hit it on the head, you just buy what's good. Shame we can'y use indie or alternative as a pointer any more.

atsonicpark 08.05.2007 06:11 PM

we need no wave to be brought back. i want to bring it back.

Sheriff Rhys Chatham 08.05.2007 06:18 PM

Let's do it.

scott v 08.05.2007 06:31 PM

Quote:

Originally Posted by atsonicpark
we need no wave to be brought back. i want to bring it back.


NO! ...no wave existed from around 1977 - 1981, it is unique period of a certain type of music that existed in a certain place therefore it should not be resurrected as the same thing, basically because it can't be. its that simple. calling it back is a contradiction to the very title statement of this thread.

Savage Clone 08.05.2007 06:33 PM

Quote:

Originally Posted by atsonicpark
we need no wave to be brought back. i want to bring it back.



Get this guy a time machine for the no wave "revival" that happened already.

Sheriff Rhys Chatham 08.05.2007 06:35 PM

Quote:

Originally Posted by scott v
NO! ...no wave existed from around 1977 - 1981, it is unique period of a certain type of music that existed in a certain place therefore it should not be resurrected as the same thing, basically because it can't be. its that simple. calling it back is a contradiction to the very title statement of this thread.


I can see your point.

Savage Clone 08.05.2007 06:36 PM

Oh, and include "lo-fi" on this list as well.
I had a feeling in the early 1990s that "lo-fi" was going to become a buzzword for music of a certain type, and not just for "bedroom production techniques" that describe the way music sounds on recordings. It came true pretty quickly, and a lot of the bands called "lo fi" are anything but.

Silent Dan Speaks 08.05.2007 06:36 PM

I just hate the word "indie". It really says nothing about the music.

Sheriff Rhys Chatham 08.05.2007 06:44 PM

I am guilty.
I use it to describe things other than music.

Danny Himself 08.05.2007 07:08 PM

Indie is a joke. I would never describe something as indie unless I was making fun of it.

atsonicpark 08.05.2007 07:18 PM

i've also decided, after years of genre confusion, scissor shock is now "digital no wave".

HaydenAsche 08.05.2007 08:32 PM

Quote:

Originally Posted by atsonicpark
i've also decided, after years of genre confusion, scissor shock is now "digital no wave".


Biggest news in music since Arab on Radar broke up.

atsonicpark 08.05.2007 08:35 PM

haha.

seriously, wait till you hear the new ep (ahh.. what the fuck, i was only going to send it to a few people but if anyone wnats it: http://www.sendspace.com/file/09ot07). it's no to the fucknig wave.

max 08.05.2007 08:39 PM

well, I (along with a friend) am planning on creating a label. actually more of a collective kinda thing. no money involved. but we are looking forward to create our space. and mostly we are doing this becuz we are sick, too, of seeing things like these happening the all time.

independent is no more, if you're out there on MTV.

Dead-Air 08.05.2007 10:29 PM

Really, the fault lies with the British "indie" charts in Melody Maker and the like, which long ago became a barometer of what was aimed at the "indie" market rather than what was produced by people independently.

Today, I find it kind of useful, in that if something I haven't heard before is described as "indie rock", I figure it'll probably be boring, cliched music made by college age kids who cop all of the moves from the interesting bands of the late '80s with none of the innovation. No telling whether they will be on a major or "indie" label of course, but they can, and will, sound the same either way.

As for No Wave revivals, as painful as it was to watch that Kill Your Idols documentary on the subject, it was worth it to hear what Lydia Lunch and James Thirlwell think of that idea!

Everyneurotic 08.05.2007 10:32 PM

ohh yeah? monosodic is no scum grind wave.


All times are GMT -5. The time now is 01:56 PM.

Powered by vBulletin Version 3.5.4
Copyright ©2000 - 2024, Jelsoft Enterprises Ltd.
All content ©2006 Sonic Youth