Sonic Youth Gossip

Sonic Youth Gossip (http://www.sonicyouth.com/gossip/index.php)
-   Non-Sonic Sounds (http://www.sonicyouth.com/gossip/forumdisplay.php?f=4)
-   -   Favourite bassists (http://www.sonicyouth.com/gossip/showthread.php?t=18955)

LittlePuppetBoy 01.15.2008 06:22 PM

Favourite bassists
 
the name explains itself.

individuals who have influenced my playing style:
Ronnie Morris-Controller.Controller
James Jamerson
whoever plays on Fela Kuti's work
Peter Hook-Joy Division
Leroy Glover-ESG
Dave Allen-Gang of Four
Whoever plays bass in Mars
Tim Wright-Pere Ubu/DNA

atsonicpark 01.15.2008 06:25 PM

Okay.

GANG OF FOUR BASSIST
JESUS LIZARD BASSIST
THEORY OF RUIN BASSIST
ANY BASSIST THAT HAS EVER PLAYED IN CAPTAIN BEEFHEART
BILL LASWELL
JOY DIVISION BASSIST
TREVOR FUCKING DUNN
CHICK FROM BRIDE OF NO NO/SCISSOR GIRLS
THINKING FELLERS UNION LOCAL # 282 BASSIST
THAT SEXY GUY FROM LIGHTNING BOLT
BRANDON SEELEY

soapbars 01.15.2008 06:54 PM

peter hook,

Danny Himself 01.15.2008 07:25 PM

Tim Luntzel is pretty cool, he looks friendly and reliable
Justin Meldal-Johnsen

and

Brian Ritchie

Bicorn Halfelven 01.15.2008 11:47 PM

Billy Fucking Sheehan

CHOUT 01.16.2008 12:02 AM

mike watt
john entwistle
jah wobble
bruce thomas
mike mills
greg norton
simon gallup
tony lombardo
bernard edwards
dave allen
etc.

gmku 01.16.2008 12:42 AM

Arthur Kane (r.i.p)

Cantankerous 01.16.2008 12:44 AM

tina weymouth

gmku 01.16.2008 12:45 AM

Kim Gordon

Cantankerous 01.16.2008 12:52 AM

kim is a good, solid, competent bass player, but among other bassists doesn't really stand out. but she is really cool.

flophousefloozie 01.16.2008 12:56 AM

Quote:

Originally Posted by Cantankerous
kim is a good, solid, competent bass player, but among other bassists doesn't really stand out. but she is really cool.


The argument of how her style works with the other guitarists can not be emphasized enough.

If she was playing a lead role, considering how long she has been doing it, her style could be quite different, and impressive.

flophousefloozie 01.16.2008 12:57 AM

Les Claypool, by the way.

flophousefloozie 01.16.2008 12:57 AM

Jaco Pastorius.

Cantankerous 01.16.2008 12:57 AM

Quote:

Originally Posted by flophousefloozie
The argument of how her style works with the other guitarists can not be emphasized enough.

If she was playing a lead role, considering how long she has been doing it, her style could be quite different, and impressive.

yes, i suppose.

flophousefloozie 01.16.2008 12:58 AM

Geddy Lee is very talented. His timing (and the band's) is outstanding...

Cantankerous 01.16.2008 01:01 AM

geezer butler is a good bass player
keith richards was great when he played bass.
john paul jones goes without saying - the whole band was a force of fucking nature.

flophousefloozie 01.16.2008 01:09 AM

Yeah, it's not about their style, though. They're a band that prides themselves in 30 minute long drum solos, and unbelievable time signatures.
That's fine with me.

flophousefloozie 01.16.2008 01:10 AM

I should also name-drop Victor Wootton

flophousefloozie 01.16.2008 01:12 AM

I mean, there are so many things that define a good bassist. Like most topics iin life these days, it's entirely about preference.

flophousefloozie 01.16.2008 01:24 AM

Quote:

Originally Posted by swa(y)
kim, by her own admission, was never all that great (as far as "complexity" is concerned) of a bassist until recent times. however, ive always liked her stuff. and i think she is a talented woman. her stuff stuff ussually tends to be simple, yeah, but it supplements what the other guys (lee/thurston) are doing rather nicely. sonic youth wouldnt/couldnt be SY without her...IF only cause of her unique voice (which yeah, has often been compared to nico's and that girl from destroy all monsters) < i still think its unique though. there'll never be another kim.


Exactly my point. She compliments the other members, and is smart for be subtle, and not overwhelming. That would destroy the sound, and ultimately, Sonic Youth.

Cantankerous 01.16.2008 01:54 AM

oh no i know. sonic youth would not be sonic youth without kim and her bass. they need to kick ibold out now.

cryptowonderdruginvogue 01.16.2008 01:59 AM

 

max 01.16.2008 02:12 AM

just 2 names:

PAUL RAVEN

STEVE DI GIORGIO

nuff said.
I love Kim's playing, too. But that's obvious.

flophousefloozie 01.16.2008 02:14 AM

She has chronic tendonitis, as I've heard it.

And thank you, Crypto.

Cantankerous 01.16.2008 02:31 AM

yeah i heard too.
still, mark ibold?

Toxa 01.16.2008 02:36 AM

Mike Watt & Bob Mair

sonicl 01.16.2008 03:18 AM

Andrew Weiss (in his Rollins Band days).

atsonicpark 01.16.2008 03:20 AM

As usual, a "list your favorite something or other" turns into a debate. Well, that's cool.

Kim isn't a good bass player, she isn't a bad player, she is just there. She is just a necessary component for a lot of sonic youth recordings. That's the thing about bass in general: it's usually there to fill space, which gives it a somewhat limiting role overall. At the same time, not many of us want to be subjected to endless bass solos. I made my list because it's bassists I personally feel had the most interesting riffs, perhaps not the person who was the best at "filling the space".

Also:
DUDE FROM RUINS

nicfit 01.16.2008 03:54 AM

Olivier Manchion (Ulan Bator - Permanent Fatal Error - Faust - Damo Suzuki's Network) he's a genius..
Massimo Pupillo (Zu - zu related stuff).
The guy who plays with Beck.
Vern Rumsey
Brian from LB
there are too many, all sexy.

atsonicpark 01.16.2008 04:19 AM

sam rivers - limp bizkit
fieldy - korn

Torn Curtain 01.16.2008 06:24 AM

In no order of preference:

Simon Gallup
Peter Hook
Mick Grondhal
Colin Greenwood
Danny Thompson
Fred Smith
Micha Acher
Andy Rourke
Paul McCartney
Tina Weymouth
Adam Clayton (yes, he does have great bass lines)

EDIT: I'll add that I'm more into melodic bassists than proficient ones (probably because I'm not a bassist myself)

gmku 01.16.2008 07:31 AM

So... how does a list of your "favorite" whatever turn into a debate???

This place is just weird sometimes.

sun city girl 01.16.2008 07:33 AM

peter hook, NEW ORDER

sonicl 01.16.2008 07:36 AM

Quote:

Originally Posted by gmku
So... how does a list of your "favorite" whatever turn into a debate???

This place is just weird sometimes.

You wanna discuss that?

gmku 01.16.2008 07:41 AM

Only if it's not a debate.

gmku 01.16.2008 07:56 AM

Sid Vicious.

gmku 01.16.2008 08:02 AM

All respects to Sid. (r.i.p.)

gmku 01.16.2008 08:04 AM

He sure couldn't play the bass though.

sarramkrop 01.16.2008 08:08 AM

Leroy Glover
John Cale
Mark Chung
Holger Czukay
Andy Rourke
Billy Nelson

RdTv 01.16.2008 08:10 AM

Charles Mingus
Mike Watt
Bootsy Collins
Jaco Pastorius
Eric Avery
Les Claypool (actually not a favorite but his talent overrides preference)
Chuck Dukowski
aaarrrhg, thats all I can remember righ now, I just woke up.....


All times are GMT -5. The time now is 06:57 AM.

Powered by vBulletin Version 3.5.4
Copyright ©2000 - 2024, Jelsoft Enterprises Ltd.
All content ©2006 Sonic Youth