Your song-by-song ratings on albums
 

Post the ratings (out of five) on each song of an album of your choice. You are allowed decimal ratings. Remember this is your opinion.
I'll go with Wowee Zowee, which is my favourite Pavement album, so I overrated it quite a bit.
We Dance - 5
Rattled by the Rush - 4.5
Black Out - 5
Brinx Job - 3
Grounded - 5
Serpentine Pad - 4
Motion Suggests Itself - 3.5
Father to a Sister of a Thought - 3.5
Extradition - 3
Best Friends Arm - 5 (I find it a breath of fresh air after the last 3 slow songs)
Grave Architecture - 5
At & T - 5
Flux = Rad - 4
Fight This Generation - 4.5
Kennel District - 5
Pueblo - 5
Half A Canyon - 3.5
Western Homes - 2.5

Now you guys go.

pick out some brazilian nuts, for your engagement, check the expiration date now, it's later than you think..... 5/5

I didn't think that "there is no castration fear" could be topped when I listened to that song for the first time. I laughed at the brazilian nuts bit.

4, 2, 8, 9, 6, 1, 9, 10.

Guess the album.

NYC ghosts and flowers ;)

Racist numbers, i tell you. Guys, watch out for him because he's tricking you into one of his racist games.

ATL?

Ok, some of my favorite records:

My Brightest Diamond - Bring me the workhorse

1. Something of an End - 4.5
2. Golden Star - 4.5
3. Gone Away - 5
4. Dragonfly - 5
5. Freak Out - 2.5
6. We Were Sparkling - 5
7. Disappear - 5
8. The Robin's Jar - 5
9. Magic Rabbit - 4.5
10.The Good & The Bad Guy - 4
11.Workhorse - 4

Television - Marquee Moon

1. See No Evil - 3.5
2. Venus - 5
3. Friction - 4
4. Marquee Moon - 5
5. Elevation - 5
6. Guiding Light - 5
7. Prove It - 4.5
8. Torn Curtain - 5

The Cure - Disintegration

1. Plainsong - 4
2. Pictures of you - 4.5
3. Closedown - 4
4. Lovesong - 4.5
5. Last dance - 4.5
6. Lullaby - 4
7. Fascination street - 5
8. Prayers for rain - 5
9. The same deep water as you - 5
10.Disintegration - 5
11.Homesick - 4.5
12.Untitled - 3.5

Neil Young - On the beach

1. Walk on - 3.5
2. (See the sky) about to rain - 4.5
3. Revolution blues - 4.5
4. For the turnstiles - 3
5. Vampire blues - 3
6. On the beach - 5
7. Motion pictures (For Carrie) - 4.5
8. Ambulance blues - 5

Neil Young - Tonight's the night

1. Tonight's The Night - 3.5
2. Speakin' Out - 4
3. World On A String - 3
4. Borrowed Tune - 5
5. Come On Baby Let's Go Downtown - 2
6. Mellow My Mind - 5
7. Roll Another Number - 4
8. Albuquerque - 5
9. New Mama - 5
10. Lookout Joe - 4
11. Tired Eyes - 5
12. Tonight's The Night-Part II - 3.5

Tim Buckley - Dream letter live in London 1968

CD 1
1. Introduction
2. Buzzin' Fly - 4
3. Phantasmagoria In Two - 5
4. Morning Glory - 4.5
5. Dolphins - 5
6. I'Ve Been Out Walking - 4
7. The Earth Is Broken - 4.5
8. Who Do You Love - 4
9. Pleasant Street/You Keep Me Hanging On - 5

CD 2
1. Love From Room 109/Strange Feelin' - 5
2. Carnival Song/Hi Lily, Hi Lo - 3
3. Hallucinations - 4.5
4. Troubadour - 5
5. Dream Letter/Happy Time - 5
6. Watfaring Stranger/You Got Me Runnin' - 5
7. Once I Was - 5

Radiohead - OK Computer

1. Airbag - 4.5
2. Paranoid Android - 5
3. Subterranean Homesick Alien - 4
4. Exit Music (For A Film) - 4
5. Let Down - 4.5
6. Karma Police - 4.5
7. Fitter Happier - 4
8. Electioneering - 3
9. Climbing Up The Walls - 5
10. No Surprises - 5
11. Lucky - 5
12. The Tourist - 4

For me:

1. Airbag - 5
2. Paranoid Android - 5
3. Subterranean Homesick Alien - 5
4. Exit Music (For A Film) - 5
5. Let Down - 5
6. Karma Police - 4.5
7. Fitter Happier - 4
8. Electioneering - 3
9. Climbing Up The Walls - 4
10. No Surprises - 4
11. Lucky - 5
12. The Tourist - 5

The only song on this album I skip is climbing up the walls, it's a bit out of place and kills the somewhat upbeat tone of electioneering and no surprises.
I'm not a bit electioneering fan though...

Sonic Youth: Goo (original album obviously:

1. Dirty Boots (5)
2. Tunic (3)
3. Mary-Christ (3)
4. Kool Thing (3)
5. Mote (4)
6. My Friend Goo (2)
7. Disappearer (4)
8. Mildred Pierce (4)
9. Cinderella's Big Score (3)
10. Scooter & Jinx (1)
11. Titanium Expose (5)

Einsturzende Neubauten: Perpetuum Mobile (I just realised that typing these German names is gonna take some time:)

1. Ich Gehe Jetzt (4)
2. Perpetuum Mobile (3)
3. Ein Leichtes Leises Sauseln (4)
4. Selbstportrait mit Kater (2)
5. Boreas (2)
6. Ein Seltener Vogel (4)
7. Ozean und Brandung (2)
8. Paradiesseits (2)
9. Youme & Meyou (3)
10. Der Weg ins Freie (2)
11. Dead Friends (Around the Corner) (4)
12. Grundstuck (2)

Needless to say I was a little disappointed with this album.

Nick Cave & the Bad Seeds: Live Seeds

1. Mercy Seat (4)
2. Deanna (3)
3. Ship Song (3)
4. Papa Won't Leave You, Henry (5)
5. Plain Gold Ring (3)
6. John Finn's Wife (3)
7. Tupelo (2)
8. Brother, My Cup is Empty (4)
9. Weeping Song (4)
10. Jack the Ripper (2)
11. Good Son (3)
12. From Her to Eternity (4)
13. New Morning (5)

Patti Smith: Horses

1. Gloria (5)
2. Redondo Beach (3)
3. Birdland (4)
4. Free Money (5)
5. Kimberly (3)
6. Break it Up (3)
7. Land (5)
8. Elegie (2)
9. My Generation (3)

Sonic Youth: Rather Ripped

1. Reena (5)
2. Incinerate (4)
3. Do You Believe in Rapture? (3)
4. Sleepin' Around (3)
5. What a Waste (3)
6. Jams Run Free (3)
7. Rats (2)
8. Turquoise Boy (3)
9. Lights Out (4)
10. The Neutral (3)
11. Pink Steam (4)
12. Or (3)
13. Helen Lundeberg (bonus track) (2)

Pretty mediocre album :(

Weezer - Pinkerton

Tired of Sex - 4.5
Getchoo - 3
No Other One - 4
Why Bother - 5
Across the Sea - 5
The Good Life - 4.5
El Scorcho - 5
Pink Triangle - 5
Falling for You - 3.5
Butterfly - 4

Funhouse-the Stooges

Down in the Street (5)
Loose (4)
Dirt (5)
1970 (5)
Fun House (4)
L A Blues (5)

Siamese Dream-Smashing Pumpkins

Cherub Rock (4)
Quiet (4)
Today (3.5)
Hummer (5)
Rocket (5)
Disarm (4)
Soma (5)
Geek USA (5)
Mayonaise (5)
Spaceboy (5)
Silverfuck (5)
Sweet Sweet (3)
Luna (4)

Filth-Swans

Stay Here (5)
Big Strong Boss (4)
Blackout (5)
Power for Power (3)
Freak (5)
Right Wrong (4)
Thank You (4)
Weakling (4)
Gang (5)

Uh, you forgot T.V. Eye, possibly the best song on that album :confused:

The Beatles- The White Album

Back In The U.S.S.R.-4
Dear Prudence-3
Glass Onion-5
Ob-La-Di Ob-La-Da-3
Wild Honey Pie-4
The Continuing Story of Bungalow Bill-4
While My Guitar Gently Weeps-4
Happiness is a Warm Gun-5
Martha My Dear-3
I'm So Tired-4
Blackbird-3
Piggies-4
Rocky Raccoon-4
Don't Pass Me By-3
Why Don't We Do It In the Road-4
I Will-3
Julia-4
Birthday-4
Yer Blues-4
Mother Nature's Son-3
EveryBody's Got Something to Hide Except for Me and My Monkey-5
Sexy Sadie-4
Helter Skelter-5
Long, Long, Long-4
Revolution 1-5
Honey Pie-3
Savory Truffle-5
Cry Baby Cry-4
Revolution 9-3
Goodnight-3

We Dance - 5
Rattled by the Rush - 5
Black Out - 5
Brinx Job - 4.5
Grounded - 6
Serpentine Pad - 4.5
Motion Suggests Itself - 5 <-- i'm wasted.
Father to a Sister of a Thought - 5
Extradition - 4
Best Friends Arm - 4
Grave Architecture - 3.5
At & T - 5
Flux = Rad - 4
Fight This Generation - 4
Kennel District - 3
Pueblo - 5
Half A Canyon - 5 <-- highly underated.
Western Homes - 2.5

WOWEE ZOWEE!! (i'll do the honours)

We dance has some fucked up lyrics, I don't know wtf hes talking about. I knew this album was going to be one of my favorite albums of all time after hearing the water start pouring during We Dance - and then the wild stomp of Rattled by the Rush :)

Radiohead-The Bends

1. Planet Telex -4
2. The Bends-4
3. High And Dry-4
4. Fake Plastic Trees-5
5. Bones-4
6. Nice Dream-3
7. Just-4
8. My Iron Lung-5
9. Bulletpoof....I Wish I was-3
10. Black Star-4
11. Sulk-3
12. Street Spirit (Fade Out)-5

The Cure - Faith

1. The Holy Hour - 5
2. Primary - 2.5
3. Other Voices - 5
4. All Cats Are Grey - 4.5
5. The Funeral Party - 5
6. Doubt - 3
7. The Drowning Man - 5
8. Faith - 5

The Cure - Pornography

1. One Hundred Years - 5
2. A Short Term Effect - 4
3. The Hanging Garden - 3.5
4. Siamese Twins - 5
5. The Figurehead - 5
6. A Strange Day - 5
7. Cold - 5
8. Pornography - 4.5

Sonic Youth - Sister

1. Schizophrenia - 5
2. Catholic Block - 5
3. Beauty Lies In The Eye - 5
4. Stereo Sanctity - 4.5
5. Pipeline/Kill Time - 5
6. Tuff Gnarl - 4
7. Pacific Coast Highway - 5
8. Hot Wire My Heart - 2
9. Cotton Crown - 4.5
10. White Cross - 4.5
11. Master-Dik - 4

The Notwist - Shrink

1. Day 7 - 5
2. Chemicals - 5
3. Another Planet - 5
4. Moron - 5
5. Electric Bear - 5
6. No Encores - 5
7. N.L. - 5
8. Shrink - 5
9. Your Signs - 5
10. 0-4 - 4

The Notwist - Neon golden

1. One Step Inside Doesn't Mean You Understand - 5
2. Pilot - 5
3. Pick Up the Phone - 5
4. Trashing Days - 5
5. This Room - 5
6. Solitaire - 4.5
7. One With the Freaks - 5
8. Neon Golden - 4.5
9. Off the Rails - 5
10. Consequence - 5

For me:

1. Dirty Boots - 4.5
2. Tunic - 4
3. Mary-Christ - 3
4. Kool Thing - 3
5. Mote - 5
6. My Friend Goo - 2
7. Disappearer - 5
8. Mildred Pierce - 4
9. Cinderella's Big Score - 5
10. Scooter & Jinx - 3
11. Titanium Expose - 4.5

Francisco López - Untitled #89

1. Untitled - 5

Down On The Street -5
Loose -5
Tv Eye -4
Dirt -3
1970 -3.5
Fun House -4
L.A. Blues -4

For me.

Fun House for me:

1. Down On The Street - 3.5
2. Loose - 4.5
3. Tv Eye - 4.5
4. Dirt - 5
5. 1970 - 5
6. Fun House - 4
7. L.A. Blues - 3.5

oh shit! you're right. I give it a 5

Only a 4 for tuff gnarl????

Jeff Buckley - Sketches for My sweetheart the drunk

CD1:
1. The Sky Is A Landfill - 5
2. Everybody Here Wants You - 4
3. Opened Once - 5
4. Nightmares By The Sea - 5
5. Yard Of Blonde Girls - 2.5
6. Witches' Rave - 4
7. New Year's Prayer - 4
8. Morning Theft - 5
9. Vancouver - 5
10. You & I - 4

CD2:
1. Nightmares By The Sea - 5
2. New Year's Prayer - 4
3. Haven't You Heard - 3
4. I Know We Could Be So Happy Baby (If We Wanted To Be) - 5
5. Murder Suicide Meteor Slave - 5
6. Back In N.Y.C. - 3.5
7. Gunshot Glitter - 5
8. Demon John - 5
9. Your Flesh Is So Nice - 2.5
10. Jewel Box - 5
11. Satisfied Mind - 5

Jeff Buckley - Grace

1. Mojo Pin - 5
2. Grace - 5
3. Last Goodbye - 5
4. Lilac Wine - 5
5. So Real - 5
6. Hallelujah - 5
7. Lover, You Shouldn'T Come Over - 5
8. Corpus Christi Carol - 5
9. Eternal Life - 4
10. Dream Brother - 5

Tim Buckley - Goodbye and Hello

1. No Man Can Find The War - 4
2. Carnival Song - 2.5
3. Pleasant Street - 5
4. Hallucinations - 4 (I prefer the live versions)
5. I Never Asked To Be Your Mountain - 5
6. Once I Was - 5
7. Phantasmagoria In Two - 5
8. Knight-Errant - 3.5
9. Goodbye And Hello - 4.5
10. Morning Glory - 5

Tim Buckley - Happy Sad

1. Strange Feelin'- 4.5
2. Buzzin' Fly - 4.5
3. Love From Room 109 At The Islander (On Pacific Coast Highway) - 5
4. Dream Letter - 5
5. Gypsy Woman - 4.5
6. Sing A Song For You - 5

Tim Buckley - Blue Afternoon

1. Happy Time - 4.5
2. Chase the Blues Away - 5
3. I Must Have Been Blind - 4.5
4. River - 5
5. So Lonely - 3
6. Cafe - 5
7. Blue Melody - 5
8. The Train - 4.5

Tim Buckley - Starsailor

1. Come Here Woman - 5
2. I Woke Up - 5
3. Monterey - 5
4. Moulin Rouge - 2.5
5. Song to the Siren - 5
6. Jungle Fire - 5
7. Starsailor - 5
8. Healing Festival - 5
9. Down by the Borderline - 5

Metallica - And Justice for All...
Blackened - 4.5
And Justice for All... - 5
Eye of the Beholder - 5
One - 5
Shortest Straw - 3
Frayed Ends of Sainity - 4
To live is to die - 5
Dyer's Eve - 4.5

Yeah, when I first listen to Sister I loved that song and it was one my faves but now I think it's not that great Sonic Youth-wise (I prefer most of the other songs on Sister).

Tuff Gnarl is the worst song on Sister.

I'm shocked. So shocked i'm starting a thread.

Lol.

Wolfgang Ambros - Es lebe der Zentralfriedhof
http://www.amazon.de/gp/product/imag...290380&s=music

1. Es lebe der Zentralfriedhof - 4
2. Wem Heut Net Schlecht Is - 3,5
3. Espresso - 4,5
4. G'söchta - 5
5. Heit Drah I Mi Ham - 3,5
6. Zwickt's Mi - 3
7. Familie Pingitzer - 5
8. De Kinettn Wo I Schlof - 5
9. A Gulasch und a Seitl Bier - 4
10. I Glaub I Geh Jetzt - 5

Laura Veirs - Carbon glacier

1. Ether Sings - 4
2. Icebound Stream - 4
3. Rapture - 5
4. Lonely Angel Dust - 4.5
5. The Cloud Room - 5
6. Wind Is Blowing Stars - 3.5
7. Shadow Blues - 5
8. Anne Bonny Rag - 2.5
9. Snow Camping - 5
10. Chimney Sweeping Man - 5
11. Salvage A Smile - 5
12. Blackened Anchor - 4.5
13. Riptide - 5

Laura Veirs - Year of meteors

1. Fire Snakes - 5
2. Galaxies - 4.5
3. Secret Someones - 5
4. Magnetized - 5
5. Parisian Dream - 5
6. Rialto - 5
7. Through The Glow - 5
8. Cool Water - 4.5
9. Spelunking - 5
10. Black Gold Blues - 4.5
11. Where Granity Is Dead - 5
12. Lake Swimming - 5
13. ? - 4

Laura Veirs - Saltbreakers (I find this record disappointing, I think it lacks the Danelectro sound, the sadness and the melodies of Year of meteors)

1. Pink Light - 4.5
2. Ocean Night Song - 5
3. Don'T Lose Yourself - 5
4. Drink Deep - 5
5. Wandering Kind - 5
6. Nightingale - 4.5
7. Saltbreakers - 4
8. To The Country - 3.5
9. Cast A Hook - 4
10. Phantom Mountain - 5
11. Black Butterfly - 4
12. Wrecking - 5

Browsing this thread I'm noticing that I'd give different notes now:

1. Airbag - 5
2. Paranoid Android - 5
3. Subterranean Homesick Alien - 4
4. Exit Music (For A Film) - 5
5. Let Down - 5
6. Karma Police - 4.5
7. Fitter Happier - 4
8. Electioneering - 2
9. Climbing Up The Walls - 5
10. No Surprises - 5
11. Lucky - 5
12. The Tourist - 4.5

Radiohead - Hail to the thief

1. 2 + 2 = 5 - 5
2. Sit down stand up - 2.5 (I like the beginning but not the ending)
3. Sail to the moon - 4.5
4. Backdrifts - 4.5
5. Go to sleep - 4
6. Where I end and you begin - 5
7. We suck young blood - 5
8. The gloaming - 2
9. There there - 5
10. I will - 5
11. A punchup at the wedding - 5
12. Myxamatosis - 5
13. Scatterbrain - 4.5
14. A wolf at the door - 5

Björk - Homogenic

1. Hunter - 5
2. Joga - 5
3. Unravel - 5
4. Bachelorette - 5
5. All neon like - 4.5
6. 5 years - 5
7. Immature - 4
8. Alarm call - 5
9. Pluto - 5
10. All is full of love - 4.5

Siouxsie & The Banshees - Juju

1. Spellbound - 4.5
2. Into the light -5
3. Arabian knights - 5
4. Halloween - 4
5. Monitor - 4
6. Night shift - 5
7. Sin in my heart - 4.5
8. Head cut - 3.5
9. Voodoo dolly - 5

The Glow Pt. 2 by the Microphones

1. I Want Wind to Blow - 4.5
2. The Glow Pt. 2 - 5.0
3. The Moon - 5.0
4. Headless Horseman - 4.0
5. My Roots Are Strong and Deep - 4.0
6. Instrumental - 4.0
7. The Mansion - 4.0
8. Untitled - 4.5
9. (something) - 3.5
10. I'll Not Contain You - 5.0
11. The Gleam Pt. 2 - 4.5
12. Map - 5.0
13. You'll Be in the Air - 3.0
14. I Want to Be Cold - 5.0
15. I Am Bored - 5.0
16. I Felt My Size - 3.0
17. Instrumental - 5.0
18. I Felt Your Shape - 3.0
19. Samurai Sword - 3.5
20. My Warm Blood - 3.0


You'd Prefer an Astronaut by Hum

1. Little Dipper - 4.5
2. The Pod - 4.5
3. Stars - 3.5
4. Suicide Machine - 3.0
5. The Very Old Man - 2.0
6. Why I Like the Robins - 3.5
7. I'd Like Your Hair Long - 4.5
8. I Hate It Too - 5.0
9. Songs of Farewell and Departure - 3.5

what the hell - im really very bored

J mascis and the fog - free so free
4 5 5 3andtwothirds 4 4 3 3 3 4

Pantera--Cowboys From Hell

Cowboys From Hell--4
Primal Concrete Sludge--3.5
Psycho Holiday--4
Heresy--4
Cemetery Gates--5
Domination--5
Shattered--4.5
Clash With Reality--3.5
Medicine Man--3
Message in Blood--4
The Sleep--4
The Art of Shredding--4.5

I like trying to play that song but the guitar solo is quite difficult :D