Rank Major SY Releases by Preference
 

My current order of preference:

1. Dirty
2. Rather Ripped
3. A Thousand Leaves
4. Experimental Jet Set, Trash and No Star
5. Evol
6. Washing Machine
7. Goo
8. Daydream Nation
9. Sister
10. Confusion is Sex/Kill Yr Idols
11. Bad Moon Rising
12. NYC Ghosts and Flowers
13. Sonic Nurse
14. Sonic Youth
15. Murray Street

Just counting full lengths..

1.)Sister
2.)Confusion is Sex/Kill Yr Idols
3.)Daydream Nation
4.)A Thousand Leaves
5.)Bad Moon Rising
6.)NYC Ghosts and Flowers
7.)Washing Machine
8.)Evol
9.)Murray Street
10.)Goo
11.)Sonic Nurse
12.)EJSTNS
13.)Rather Ripped
14.)Dirty

1. sister
2. daydream nation
3. washing machine
4. a thousand leaves
5. evol
6. dirty
7. murray street
8. confusion is sex + kill yr idols
9. bad moon rising
10. sonic youth
11. goo
12. sonic nure
13. experimental jet set
14. rather ripped
15. nycg&f

1. Confusion is Sex/Kill Yr Idols
2. The Whitey Album
3. Bad Moon Rising
4. Sonic Youth
5. Experimental Jet Set, Trash and No Star
6. Dirty
7. Sonic Nurse
8. Rather Ripped
9. Goo
10. Daydream Nation
11. Washing Machine

Unheard:
12. Sister
13. NYC Ghosts and Flowers
14. A Thousand Leaves
15. Murray Street
16. Evol

Even though there seem to be alot of these threads:

1. Sister
2. Murray Street
3. Daydream Nation
4. Confusion is Sex/Kill Yr. Idols
5. Bad Moon Rising
6. Goo
7. EVOL
8. Washing Machine
9. EJTNS
10. NYCG&F
11. A Thousand Leaves
12. Sonic Nurse
13. Rather Ripped
14. Dirty

It is....what we are seeing is something symptomatic of a forum disease, where the hard-core fans fall prey to popular "in-crowd" opinions about the early albums being somehow better, because it's "cool" to think that way.

Talk to almost anyone else who is not a hardcore SY forum nerd, and they'll agree with me.

What do I care if almost everyone here has bad taste? Why don't you stop typing messages about it?

CIS/KYI
Murray Street
Sister
BMR
Washing Machine
Day Dream Nation
NYCG&F
EVOL
ATL





Dirty
Goo
EJSTNS
Rather Ripped
SOnic Nurse

1.) A Thousand Leaves
2.) Sister
3.) Daydream Nation
4.) Confusion is Sex
5.) Dirty
6.) Bad Moon Rising
7.) Evol
8.) Murray Street
9.) Goo
10.) Sonic Nurse
11.) EJST + NS
12.) Washing Machine
13.) NYCG + F
14.) Rather Ripped

But this is right now, its always changing.

Nurse
A Thousand Leaves
Washing Machine
Daydream Nation
Experimental Jet Set
Dirty
Murray Street
Rather Ripped
Goo
NYC
SY
Sister
Evol
Bad Moon Rising
Confusion

Why do you think everyone here has bad taste? You seem pretty conceited. Not everyone has to agree with you.

My preference:

1. Daydream Nation
2. Sister
3. Goo
4. Washing Machine
5. EVOL
6. Sonic Nurse
7. Murray Street
8. A Thousand Leaves
9. NYC Ghost and Flowers
10. Dirty
11. Confusion is Sex
12. Rather Ripped
13. Bad Moon Rising
14. Experimental Jet Set, Trash and No Star
15. Made In USA
16. Goodbye 20th Century

My list is right.

See Assblaster's comment above--he was using the fact that most of the people who had posted in this thread so far dislike Rather Ripped in order to try and prove that it is a bad album and that I have poor taste for liking it. He is the conceited one. Are you his friend or something?

Mine changes around a lot too. It depends on what mood I am in, what album I happen to be listening to more at the time, phases of the moon, weather, etc.

It may be fun to you, but it's not funny to be a troll. You need to stop immediately following behind me and criticizing me whenever I express my opinion.

1. Sister
2. Daydream Nation
3. Bad Moon Rising
4. Confusion
5. Goo
6. EVOL
7. A Thousand Leaves
8. Murray Street
9. Sonic Nurse
10. Washing Machine
11. Rather Ripped
12. NYC Ghosts & Flowers
13. Experimental Jet Set
14. Dirty
15. Sonic Youth

Yes, I know what a troll is. Your mother is a troll.

Nope. Don't know him. Never met him. Don't care. There's just way too much arguing on this board. It just seems trite and pointless. People are always going to have different opinions on the music discussed in this board, so what's the point of name calling and insults? It just comes across as stupid. I mean, we are all talking to each other via computers. Almost no one here really knows who anybody else really is, so it's just really stupid to argue with people we don't know and can't physically confront in real life. That's all I have to say about that. I'm done arguing from now on. No more arguing for me!

Like I care.