Sonic Youth Gossip

Sonic Youth Gossip (http://www.sonicyouth.com/gossip/index.php)
-   Sonic Gossip (http://www.sonicyouth.com/gossip/forumdisplay.php?f=3)
-   -   Rank Major SY Releases by Preference (http://www.sonicyouth.com/gossip/showthread.php?t=3148)

Gookid 06.19.2006 08:31 PM

Either most of the posters here are under 16, or they're retarded.

Daycare Nation 06.19.2006 08:31 PM

Quote:

Originally Posted by AssBlaster
And since Atari is the #3 biggest fan of Sonic Youth...you can take it as gospel (even thought NYC Ghosts + Flowers is way better than murray street and sonic nurse)....

You heard it hear....Rather Ripped is among the worst 4 albums in the catalog.


You're totally proving my point. People just believe certain albums are better than others because of what other people influence them to believe, not because they are actually good, or because you have formed a true opinion. Why should I believe anything aout RR because of what you or anyone else on this forum says? LOL

Daycare Nation 06.19.2006 08:32 PM

Quote:

Originally Posted by Gookid
Either most of the posters here are under 16, or they're retarded.


Amen

atari 2600 06.19.2006 08:36 PM

I love RR.
I also love ATL, especially live, even though it is ranked at the bottom.

Daycare Nation 06.19.2006 08:39 PM

Quote:

Originally Posted by atari 2600
I love RR.
I also love ATL, especially live, even though it is ranked at the bottom.


Cool...So you've just proven that although RR may be ranked at the bottom of a list, that doesn't mean that people don't love it.

Given some time, it may even work its way up some lists.

Daycare Nation 06.19.2006 08:40 PM

LOL! I love Assblaster's sig line.

noah 06.19.2006 08:53 PM

pretty similar to toxic j:
1.bad moon rising
2.confusion is sex
3.sister
4.evol
5.sonic death
6.sonic youth
7.jet set
8.daydream nation
9.nyc ghosts and flowers
10.a thousand leaves
11.washing machine
12.dirty
13.nurse
14.murray street
15.goo
16.rather ripped

China~Nurse 06.19.2006 08:56 PM

Quote:

Originally Posted by Gookid
Either most of the posters here are under 16, or they're retarded.


Kind of sad. I signed on thinking that this would be a great place to talk about SY but there are a few people who are so dead set on making those who don't agree with their opinion unwanted.


Oh, and people who dislike Sonic Nurse are losers! :p

Daycare Nation 06.19.2006 08:58 PM

Quote:

Originally Posted by China~Nurse
Kind of sad. I signed on thinking that this would be a great place to talk about SY but there are a few people who are so dead set on making those who don't agree with their opinion unwanted.


Oh, and people who dislike Sonic Nurse are losers! :p


So true! Leave us alone, Assblaster!

sonikjuice 06.19.2006 09:39 PM

(1) Daydream Nation
(2) Sister
(3) EVOL
(4) Goo
(5) Dirty
(6) Bad Moon Rising
(7) Nurse
(8) Murray Street
(9) Rather Ripped
(10) Confusion is Sex/Kill Your Idols
(11) Washing Machine
(12) EJSTNS
(13) A Thousand Leaves
(14) NYCGF

krastian 06.20.2006 02:03 AM

I only like 3 or 4 of their albums, but I'm still a big fan......I'm just here for the free Bud Light.

_slavo_ 06.20.2006 02:13 AM

Quote:

Originally Posted by China~Nurse
Kind of sad. I signed on thinking that this would be a great place to talk about SY but there are a few people who are so dead set on making those who don't agree with their opinion unwanted.


Oh, and people who dislike Sonic Nurse are losers! :p


you kind of got the point.

_slavo_ 06.20.2006 02:19 AM

does every second fucking thread need to be a place of twisted verbal clashes between Daycare and Assblaster? come on, grow up or create your own discussion board, because reading all this crap is rather exhausting.

porkmarras 06.20.2006 03:43 AM

Even though Jetset gets the bad press most of the time(and that's because quite a few folks believe everything that they read),it happens to be one of my favourite SY albums.Dare you say that i'm 16,i've known SY since Daydream Nation wich makes it a hefty 19 years so you little indie people can fuck off.

girlslikeyou 06.20.2006 04:37 AM

Quote:

Originally Posted by Daycare Nation
It is....what we are seeing is something symptomatic of a forum disease, where the hard-core fans fall prey to popular "in-crowd" opinions about the early albums being somehow better, because it's "cool" to think that way.

Talk to almost anyone else who is not a hardcore SY forum nerd, and they'll agree with me.



i agree with you.

jean-nicolas 06.20.2006 06:15 AM

1:A thousand leaves
2:Washing machine
3:Made in USA
4:Murray street
5:daydream nation
6:dirty
7:Experimental jet set trash and no star
8:New York city ghost and flowers
9:Sister
10:SYR4 goodbye 20th century
11:Sonic nurse
12:Sonic youth
13:Goo
14:Evol
15:Bad moon rising
16:Confusion is sex/kill your idol
17:The whitey album
18:Rather ripped

Dues 06.20.2006 06:23 AM

Preference?
 
01. EVOL / 02. Daydream Nation / 03. Washing Machine / 04. Sonic Nurse / 05. Dirty / 06. Sister / 07. Murray Street / 08. Confusion is Sex—Kill your Idols / 09. Goo / 10. Sonic Youth / 11. Bad Moon Rising / 12. Rather Ripped / 13. NYC Ghosts & Flowers / 14. Experimental Jet Set, Trash And No Star / 15. A Thousand Leaves

But actually, I prefer them in the chronological order that they came out. Can't think of one without its predecessor(s)/successor(s).
The list/sequence above just seems weird.

_slavo_ 06.20.2006 06:54 AM

IMO Rather Ripped is not so bad (after like 3 listens)..It's definitely better than Jetset, I guess.

Daycare Nation 06.20.2006 11:48 AM

Quote:

Originally Posted by girlslikeyou
i agree with you.


Cool.

--Daycare

porkmarras 06.20.2006 12:11 PM

Quote:

Originally Posted by Daycare Nation
Cool.

--Daycare

 


All times are GMT -5. The time now is 09:24 PM.

Powered by vBulletin Version 3.5.4
Copyright ©2000 - 2024, Jelsoft Enterprises Ltd.
All content ©2006 Sonic Youth