Sonic Youth Gossip

Sonic Youth Gossip (http://www.sonicyouth.com/gossip/index.php)
-   Non-Sonic Sounds (http://www.sonicyouth.com/gossip/forumdisplay.php?f=4)
-   -   Unpopular Musical Opinions (http://www.sonicyouth.com/gossip/showthread.php?t=972)

atari 2600 04.16.2006 05:18 PM

Quote:

Originally Posted by Laila
majority of SY songs are annoying and hurt my ears. Sorry but screeching guitar noise is not music.


why are you here at this forum?

1st she starts a thread at the old board called "I don't like Lee", now this. Step the fuck off. Don't bother answering the question; you've been ignore listed.


Quote:

Originally Posted by Hip Priest
I like Sting.

The Dream of the Blue Turtles is a good album. Bring on the Night is an okay live one. Ten Summoner's Tales is a great pop rock record.

Hip Priest 04.16.2006 05:22 PM

Quote:

Originally Posted by krastian
Without The Police?


I like Sting much more without the Police.

He's a nice guy, he cares about things, and he has made many a fine song (and LP). You can't mess with songs like 'Shadows in the Rain', 'Seven Days', If I Ever Lose My Faith', Fields of Gold' etc. I think Sting has a bit of class about him. Sorry.

TheDom 04.16.2006 05:23 PM

Quote:

Originally Posted by atari 2600
why are you here at this forum?

1st she starts a thread at the old board called "I don't like Lee", now this. Step the fuck off. You've been ignore listed.


Well, she wants to know if L7 are hispanic... That's reason enough

krastian 04.16.2006 05:38 PM

Quote:

Originally Posted by Hip Priest
I like Sting much more without the Police.

He's a nice guy, he cares about things, and he has made many a fine song (and LP). You can't mess with songs like 'Shadows in the Rain', 'Seven Days', If I Ever Lose My Faith', Fields of Gold' etc. I think Sting has a bit of class about him. Sorry.


No need to apologize.

Danny Himself 04.16.2006 05:41 PM

I've been getting more acquainted with the Beach Boys recently. After hearing Lee singing 'I know there's an answer' I dug out my pet sounds record and just got right into it. It's an extreme, I know, but it's pretty sonic when you get into it. Listen to the organs on 'Here Today' and you'll know what I mean.

Also, The Violent Femmes. Dude! Too cool for... country. The drummer is really friendly, y'know.

DoubleNickels 04.16.2006 05:56 PM

On top with Smashing Pumpkins

Adore and Machine are great albums, and Gish isn't that good. Siamese Dream is over rated and MCIS is much better.

khchris(original) 04.16.2006 06:01 PM

Quote:

Originally Posted by schizophrenicroom
i hate most springsteen.



1. The Shins are overrated and unoriginal.
2. Interpol are overrated and unoriginal.
3. The Killers are nothing more than a 21st century "new wave" band.
4. Lightning Bolt is a ruins ripoff.
5. Wolf Eyes wishes they were half as witty as Black Dice.
6. 95% of the people on this board didn't know who Jim O'Rourke was before his work on SYR.
7. NYG&F was a horrible album for SY standards.
8. Locust are an incredible band.
9. US Punk Rock > UK Punk Rock
10. Sex Pistols and Steve Jones in particular, ripped of the Dolls ridiculously.
11. Sub Pop has gone soft.
12. David Grubbs > Jim O'Rourke
13. The Postal Service sound like generic car commercial music.
14. The Flaming Lips new album is great.
15. Prog reemergence is "so 2000".
16. Faust > Can
17. Slowdive is unoriginal and just another carbon copy of My Bloody Valentine.
18. Shoegazer is "so early 90s" and that Ride, Lush, Chapterhouse, Catherine Wheel, and Slowdive all sound the same.
19. People in Los Angeles need to get over shoegazer and realize that there was much better music after 1992.
20. The last great true hardcore punk movement was Gravity in the early 90s.
21. Royal Trux > Jon Spencer
22. Majority of the new psychedelic noise folk bands today cannot pull off what Califone/Red Red Meat were doing 15 years ago.
23. Jim O'Rourke never made a huge noticeable impact on Sonic Youth.
24. The Hypnotics were doing stoner rock much better than the 21st century stoner rock bands.
25. Trans Am still kick ass.

I could go on but I'm sure this will be enough to create a war of words.

khchris(original) 04.16.2006 06:05 PM

Oh yeah:

As far as writing music, Brian Wilson >The Beatles.

khchris(original) 04.16.2006 06:08 PM

Just remembered:

Stereolab criminally ripped off 2 bands(and songs in particular):

The Beach Boy's "Let's go away for awhile"(off PET SOUNDS)
and
Neu's "Hallo Gallo"(off their s/t)

Danny Himself 04.16.2006 06:08 PM

"MCIS" was a masterpiece, and although lots of people don't like "Adore" I think it was pretty rad. Interpol are pretty good (haha, Im not starting anything I hope).

khchris(original) 04.16.2006 06:10 PM

I'm lovin' this thread!

I didn't know I had so many complaints about music.

khchris(original) 04.16.2006 06:11 PM

Quote:

Originally Posted by Danny Himself
"MCIS" was a masterpiece, and although lots of people don't like "Adore" I think it was pretty rad. Interpol are pretty good (haha, Im not starting anything I hope).



Na, you're entitled to your opinion(which was what this thread was about).

Also, majority of people would disagree with me and side with you on that issue.

khchris(original) 04.16.2006 06:13 PM

Holy fuck!

Another:


Guns and Roses are not cool, never were cool, and people in Los Angeles need to stop pumping that shit in the clubs and just remember 80s hollywood metal is not cool, was not cool, and will never be cool.

khchris(original) 04.16.2006 06:14 PM

This one is related to SY:

Kim's bass playing > Jim's bass playing when it comes to Sonic Youth's music.

finding nobody 04.16.2006 06:23 PM

everyone is getting told! is there anyone who hasn't got an artist they love trampled on?

TheDom 04.16.2006 06:25 PM

Quote:

Originally Posted by khchris(original)
This one is related to SY:

Kim's bass playing > Jim's bass playing when it comes to Sonic Youth's music.


That is a good point, and I agree. Jim's basslines were more complex and with more note-heavy, but they followed along very closely with what the guitars were doing. I like how Kim's lines are kind of off and sort of out of tune with the guitars and stuff, and how they are very simple but really go good with the music. It's a nice contrast with the music.

RockerNino 04.16.2006 06:25 PM

The Rolling Stones are WAY overrated.

dietzer123 04.16.2006 06:26 PM

madonna is a wayward would that needs to be clubbed to death like a baby seal.

dietzer123 04.16.2006 06:27 PM

and it's about fucking time we put the stones out to pasture. after that shit they pulled with bittersweet symphany they needed a beating anyways

HaydenAsche 04.16.2006 06:29 PM

Nirvana is boring.
Sonic Youth aren't the greatest band ever. I love them and all but some of you need to get off your knees and stop bowing for them.
Kind of like Khchris said Black Dice > Hair Police > Wolf Eyes
Yellow Swans kick major ass
Jamie Stewart is the greatest musical mind of the last decade
Sufjan Stevens deserves a fucking grammy for how good his shit is
"I'm Wide Awake. It's Morning." Was a decent record
the Postal Service are great
Same for Death Cab, the first Taking Back Sunday cd, and alot of Brand New

nomadicfollower 04.16.2006 06:45 PM

Quote:

Originally Posted by RockerNino
The Rolling Stones are WAY overrated.



Yes! Thank you.



And I agree 100% with the Guns 'n' Roses put down.


The Melvins and the Butthole Surfers suck.

nomadicfollower 04.16.2006 06:45 PM

Also, Rapeman's Two Nuns and a Pack Mule is one of the few PERFECT records.

Danny Himself 04.16.2006 06:51 PM

Fat Worm of Error have the best band name in the world, ish. Too bad they kinda suck.

HaydenAsche 04.16.2006 06:54 PM

Quote:

Originally Posted by Danny Himself
Fat Worm of Error have the best band name in the world, ish. Too bad they kinda suck.


I dunno. I like 16 Bitch Pile-Up just a little more.

Everyneurotic 04.16.2006 06:54 PM

i liked black dice a lot more when they used guitars and less synths

aaron dilloway solo is way better than wolf eyes

london calling is an ok album with only a couple of good songs

hair metal is a FUN musical genre. both intentionally and unintentionally

clap your hands say yeah is the worst band ever to be hyped

interpol sucks

cripple crow sucks. devendra is going down

what happened to diverse thinking?

fuck you heroes!!

Everyneurotic 04.16.2006 06:55 PM

Quote:

Originally Posted by nomadicfollower
Also, Rapeman's Two Nuns and a Pack Mule is one of the few PERFECT records.


that's a true statement

HaydenAsche 04.16.2006 06:55 PM

Hair Metal sucked. End of story.

Clap Your Hands Say Yes is horrible. Thanks for pointing that out. I must have forgotten them.

Rolling Stones are a bunch of dinosaurs.

Laila 04.16.2006 07:09 PM

Fine then i won't post on this fucking board anymore. hello! the name of the thread is unpopular musical opinions! i like sy but i don't like it when my ears hurt and i get a headache! SY has alot of great songs but they have alot of not so great ones.

Danny Himself 04.16.2006 07:09 PM

Quote:

Originally Posted by HaydenAsche
I dunno. I like 16 Bitch Pile-Up just a little more.


Now that you think of it, most bands on the Ecstatic Peace ticket have awesome names. Jackie-O Motherfucker, Smegma, and My Cat is an Alien is to name but a few.

dietzer123 04.16.2006 07:41 PM

i think some of bright eyes stuff is brilliant

Pablitzen 04.16.2006 07:42 PM

Quote:

Originally Posted by Laila
Fine then i won't post on this fucking board anymore. hello! the name of the thread is unpopular musical opinions! i like sy but i don't like it when my ears hurt and i get a headache! SY has alot of great songs but they have alot of not so great ones.


start with yr own opinion...then we will follow the pattern :D

DoubleNickels 04.16.2006 07:45 PM

I like Interpol a lot.

I liked Billy Corgan's solo record.

Wolf Parade is a fucking good band

But meh, we all have our own opinions.

I will argue that Jim's bass playing works better for SY as a 5 piece, but between Kim and Jim for a bass spot in a 4 piece? Kim takes that.

nature scene 04.16.2006 08:18 PM

radiohead is boring

sonic youth's lyrics mostly suck. Lee's are usually good. (of course the music is always amazing)

magik markers are horrible

HaydenAsche 04.16.2006 08:59 PM

I will second Magik Markers is horrible until I am blue in the face.

Elisa can choke on skeet and die.

atari 2600 04.16.2006 09:08 PM

not unpopular with this board
but unpopular with the general tastes of the public is that The Sopranos (which have been using some terrific music this season) missed a perfect opportunity to close tonight's program with Sonic Youth's "New Hampshire".
Instead they used "The Fourth of July" by pseudo-L.A.-punkers X. khchris actually professed once that he likes this horrible band. I'd also like to remark that his contention with Steve Jones is a stupid one.

That's okay though, I got Duran Duran, Arcadia & Sade on my '80s list in that other thread haha. Which makes me remember that I forgot The Power Station on my list. That was a pretty damn good pop rock record. hey Hip Priest, Sting sings backup on a track on the Arcadia record. Also in 1985 ,he famously did back up vocals on the classic Dire Strait's Brothers in Arms track, Money for Nothing. Sting says his "I want my MTV" line was a parody of Don't Stand So Close to Me.

oh yeah, a little bit of some news for all you (well, most) music-hatin' fucktards:
I read that the May 9th Gilmore Girls season finale with Sonic Youth (news at main page) is actually an episode where Grant-Lee Phillips (something has always irked me about that guy) is leaving to go tour with Neil Young so the town (i guess, i've never seen the show) holds a Troubapalooza Festival & performers that will be featured (for seconds, i imagine at a time although SY were listed first in the blurb) are gonna be Sonic Youth, Yo La Tengo (recently they played a show with John Zorn & Sun Ra), Joe Pernice (now with the Pernice Brothers, formerly of Northampton's own The Scud Mountain Boys), Sparks (no shit...Thurston got to work with one of his absolute faves), & Mary Lynn Rajskub (who playes Chloe on 24).

...to quote John Lennon: "strange days indeed"

marleypumpkin 04.16.2006 09:12 PM

Quote:

Originally Posted by RockerNino
The Rolling Stones are WAY overrated.


I agree 100%

HaydenAsche 04.16.2006 09:13 PM

Quote:

Originally Posted by AssBlaster
Wait, are you saying that X isn't really from L.A. or that they aren't really punk?

If it happens to be the latter and not the former, I believe you meant to type the words in this order "L.A. pseudo-punkers".

If it was the former, where are they actually from?

Love,
Disco Daddy


I love it when people are assholes.

Everyneurotic 04.16.2006 09:15 PM

ahhh, x are good!!

not as spin and most people try to say but we're desperate and johnny hit and run pauline are classic punk songs on par with anything you want to put besides.

sure, i hate their pseudo intellectual-poet pretentiousness but billy zoom was a massive guitarist

and they were from like around la, i think they lived in orange county or around. and i know john doe was from baltimore and moved to cali.

HaydenAsche 04.16.2006 09:20 PM

Quote:

Originally Posted by AssBlaster
Really? I find that assholes are on the whole completely intolerable. I would much rather be in the company of people who are not overtly hostile as opposed to those who I find to be genuine and welcoming.

I'm sorry that we disagree, but I do not judge you because of it.

On the contrary, I am of the surprising opinion that you are quite lovable Mr. Asche.

Love,
A.B.


I find you to be quite lovable as well.

I like it when people point out other people's mistakes is what I should have said not "I like it when people are assholes."

dietzer123 04.16.2006 09:21 PM

x fucking rocked folks


All times are GMT -5. The time now is 06:52 AM.

Powered by vBulletin Version 3.5.4
Copyright ©2000 - 2024, Jelsoft Enterprises Ltd.
All content ©2006 Sonic Youth