Sonic Youth Gossip

Sonic Youth Gossip (http://www.sonicyouth.com/gossip/index.php)
-   Non-Sonic Sounds (http://www.sonicyouth.com/gossip/forumdisplay.php?f=4)
-   -   Nas vs. Bob Dylan (http://www.sonicyouth.com/gossip/showthread.php?t=5957)

ted_kennedy 09.10.2006 05:34 PM

Quote:

Originally Posted by Cantankerous
i'm sorry, but this thread is just fucking absurd.


Why?

Cantankerous 09.10.2006 05:35 PM

Quote:

Originally Posted by ted_kennedy
Why?

take a wild guess.

ted_kennedy 09.10.2006 05:38 PM

Give me a clue, numbnuts

atari 2600 09.10.2006 05:42 PM

She doesn't have nuts.

She's got ovaries & tits.

Yo, is "numbnuts" your favorite diss?

Danny Himself 09.10.2006 05:45 PM

This thread is high art. Monty Python would be proud of it's absurdity.

k-krack 09.10.2006 05:45 PM

i must spread rep before giving it to atari again. hahahahaha (in reference to the bunch of lyrics)

atari 2600 09.10.2006 05:45 PM

Quote:

Originally Posted by Danny Himself
This thread is high art. Monty Python would be proud of it's absurdity.


it's "its"

sorry to be a stickler...

That was never five minutes just now. - Argument Clinic

Gulasch Noir 09.10.2006 05:52 PM

hahahaha, reading the first line of if i ruled the world was enough to be convinced

atari 2600 09.10.2006 05:55 PM

It's too bad Toilet & Bowels isn't here to agree with ted_kennedy since he's up on all the rap, hates me with a passion, & probably likes to downplay any Dylan greatness because that's the type of person he is...he often has shown a penchant for defining his own supposed uniqueness by being contrarian to what's accepted as great in the rock canon.

porkmarras 09.10.2006 05:57 PM

I came back to this thread expecting a corpse but still nothing.Hurry up people!

k-krack 09.10.2006 05:59 PM

i don't really like dylans music much, but its plain dumb to even try to compare the lyrics of one such as nas to one of such utter greatness, and legendary status.

what do you mean porkie?

porkmarras 09.10.2006 06:01 PM

Murder,blood and sadness.That's what i mean.

atari 2600 09.10.2006 06:02 PM

Hey, Nas & I are both Virgos.

NAS LYRICS

"Pussy Killz"

Ugh
Crazy
HA [echo]
Yo pussy kill me
Ugh Ugh
Ya ya ya
Huh
Ugh Ugh Ugh

Pussy kill me when I was born (what)
Pardon me I rephrase it departed mommy wound decayin
I look at the bright side, the fact that I got a life side
Born 73 (September right Nas)
True, Virgo child
The first thing I learned is money makes the world go round
On a small planet, its 10 women to 1 man
I wonder how we managed
To say vows and walk a straight line in marriage
Niggas is some nasty creatures, bitches even nastier
They throw it at your boy and it’s hard for me to pass it up
Freaky ho's licken niggas ass and nuts
Stupid bitch bragen till her baby dad went nuts
And now were looking for me, 2 cars deep
Rollin up on niggas
Barrel out da window, Asking (you nas peeps)
I can't here dat 2 4 5 nigga grad at
Pass it to me sucker for love niggas I blast at
I swear my dick is gonna get me into trouble, I pissin bubble
I thought I felt a sharp pain betta stick to rubbers
When lain, hooker after hooker down and day
Watch out for diseases, the doctors can't name em
Just a thought we all fuck the same chicks
Some play like they innocent
Fucken entertainers, and basket ball players
The bitch is a ho
But still some of yall il say ya put your dick in her dough
You’re just a nigger that life to her, she thought your crazy
Now your monkey ass want to shoot the pimp that pipes her
She had your baby, now you a lifa
The suicide note you write her
Pussy kills

[Chorus X2]
O what a thrill inside a bitch feel
Gotta be strong and handle, it is real
Pussy killz
Mad shots keep a nigga open
Bitch have a nigga’s gun smoking
pussy killz

My nigga James got married same girl he went to school with
Nice girl, nerd with glasses, he was to stuck
Studied for her masters, part time nurse
I tell you how superb the ass is, but who’s looking
And I mean that’s my man, maybe I just took a peek
Maybe I wondered what it would be like, syke, cause James and me like
I was with A Z like, Luke and Han Solo
Fuckin with niggas girls, forbidden, that’s a no no
It’s death and we’re real niggas civilized guards
And there ain’t to many niggas like Nas I’m trust worthy
Plus I know a dude that caught his wife cheatin
Killed his baby, killed his wife, and took his own life even
Happy for James cause real bitches hard to come by
This nigga found one, I told him he was lucky an clown something
Rollin up duckies while watching Roy Jones in round one
He froze put his to the t.v. about an inch close
Move outa the way nigga what the fuck the matter with you, you blind
He pointed to the front row, thought he was losing his mind
She was supposed to be with her sick mother
Left for the weekend, stress when she was leaving, now she next to some nigga cheesin
He’s having trouble breathing (breathing)
He pictured them making noises, grindin em and kissin em
Yellin, ain’t no telling where her lips have bin
Left her foul messages, she came home no lesser then
Ten minutes later and they start wrestling, and screamin
She said she missed her flight that evening
She never left, she wasn’t at the fight u speakin
That’s Vegas this is New York you bugin
I held up my hand for dat, but he wouldn’t touch it
I was like when u started actin like that, this is dumbness
Gave me a crazy look and started swingin punches
I ducked couldn’t believe it, the niggas so wet
He got his gad and started squeezin, hit two police men
Neighbors dialed 911 they heard the thumpin
Wounded cops kicked in the door and started dumpin
Me and his wife hit to the floor she smelt strange
My comrade was breathing no more they killed James

[Chorus X2]
O what a thrill inside a bitch feel
Gotta be strong and handle, it is real
Pussy killz
Mad shots keep a nigga open
Bitch have a nigga’s gun smoking
pussy killz

---


"Virgo"
(feat. Ludacris)

One…two…yeah…huh…Nasir

[Chorus - Nas]
Baby girl won’t you come and hold my hand
Won’t you come and chill out with the Virgo
Hey girl, just come and hold my hand
Won’t you come and just chill with the Virgo
We sippin’ on Merlot
You ain’t got be my girl though
I’ll drop you off at Woolabee and Merdo
Smash with the Virgo
Ain’t got to take your shirt off
But see me convince your homegirl though

[Nas]
Uh, she says some life is too hard
She says that she wanna come build and with the god
Promise me that she gonna play her part
Cuz what I spit gets straight to her heart
And she damn fine, feet hammertime
Damn if I mind
Long as the butt bubble in back of your waistline
I don’t waste time, I gotta get-get on it
Just you and me, two glasses….
In the club scene where I met Miss Green Eyes
She walked by asking me “Are you Nas?”
“Why?”
“If you was I’d be totally T.W.I”
“What’s that?”
“Totally With It. T.W.I”
“Ha, well here I am”
“Yep, I’m the man”
“Bartender, put a Cosmo in that girl hand”
So here we standin’ before I begin
Homegirl made a knot out of the cherry stem
Tongue skills, yea I like that
Now we on the right track
Straight to my Phantom called ‘Africa Black’
Ever since then, she been yappin’ her track
Told her friends now they hollerin’ behind her back
Sing

[Chorus - Nas]
Baby girl won’t you come and hold my hand
Won’t you come and chill out with the Virgo
Hey girl, just come and hold my hand
Won’t you come and just chill with the Virgo
We sippin’ on Merlot
You ain’t got be my girl though
I’ll drop you off at Woolabee and Merdo
Smash with the Virgo
Ain’t got to take your shirt off
But see me convince your homegirl though

[Ludacris]
Now I was so fresh and so fly in diamonds
When I stepped up in the club even my eyes was shinin, “bling!”
A little cute thing said, “What’s your name?”
I put my necklace in her face and told her “Read the chain”
Ooh, ooh so stuck up
Told me “Shut the fuck up”
Blow! Ludacris is in the hot Luke house
The needle hit the record, they was playin this song
All the ladies hit the floor and it was uh-uh on
Live forever like ‘Fame’, let the Leroys dance
While I’m laid back chillin in my b-boy stance
Could be a little pop lockin if your girl’s tops droppin
But watch for cock blockin all my coochie stock options
But later for that ASDAQ throw ‘em on the fast track
Make ‘em swip-swap Nasty N.A.S pass that
Honey in the black cuz I’m feelin her curves
She looked down and what I had is that wa-wa word
Why only serve one when you can serve up two
Then at the bachelor’s pad doin what the Virgos do
And these women so shy, but get loud undercover
So we can have sex, but I can’t be your lover!
Sing

[Chorus - Ludacris]
Baby girl won’t you come and hold my hand
Won’t you come and just chill with the Virgo
Hey girl, just come and hold my hand
Won’t you come and chill out with the Virgo
We sippin’ on Merlot
You ain’t got be my girl though
I’ll drop you off at Peachtree and Merlot
Smash with the Virgo
Ain’t got to take your shirt off
But see me convince your homegirl though

ted_kennedy 09.10.2006 06:02 PM

Why is it? Its so sad that fans of a band like sonic youth are so closed minded to other sounds and cultures.

I guess the apple does fall far from the tree...

HaydenAsche 09.10.2006 06:04 PM

You're an idiot.

porkmarras 09.10.2006 06:06 PM

I quite like some Nas and i don't mind some Dylan either.I want homicide and rivers of blood for my own perverse entertainment though.

k-krack 09.10.2006 06:07 PM

Quote:

Originally Posted by ted_kennedy
Why is it? Its so sad that fans of a band like sonic youth are so closed minded to other sounds and cultures.

I guess the apple does fall far from the tree...


wrong. you haven't been around here long, though. i can understand yr apparent mental retardation in this situation. just stop talking about it now, and it won't get any worse.

atari 2600 09.10.2006 06:09 PM

Quote:

Originally Posted by ted_kennedy
Why is it? Its so sad that fans of a band like sonic youth are so closed minded to other sounds and cultures.

I guess the apple does fall far from the tree...



We're not colse-minded. We discuss all kinds of music here. It's just that your topic statement is a bit, like Cantankerous stated, "absurd."
I know you were just trying to educate us about some of the parallels of Nas' message to some of Dylan's more radical sentiments & like I wrote before, he is, from what I've read, more gifted of a rapper than most, but I still prefer Public Enemy for meaningful raps. That may sound whitebread & dated to you, but it's my informed opinion.


Quote:

Originally Posted by ted_kennedy
The race card is relevant, so dont dodge it. As a proportion of the cultural establishment in the US a tiny fraction is black. Inevitably, the results to these types of polls, and simple dominant opinions, will reflect the makeup of the (white) people that create them.



Quote:

Originally Posted by porkmarras
I quite like some Nas and i don't mind some Dylan either.I want homicide and rivers of blood for my own perverse entertainment though.


How can you deny, ted_kennedy, that some of Nas' music is decidely gangsta in orientation?

Like Chuck D himself, most of us here are just a wee bit too intelligent to embrace gangsta rap although many here, including myself, cannot deny the musical qualities of N.W.A.

To be absolutely honest, you are coming off as the one with a racist bent.

porkmarras 09.10.2006 06:12 PM

This forum is more tolerant than most in fact.Look,some kind soul even created a world music thread today so it's hardly right to say that all SY fans are narrow minded.Some certainly are but there are many who are not.

ted_kennedy 09.10.2006 06:13 PM

That tops it all - the Public Enemy defense. People that know nothing about rap always say they like PE. Thats because they say things liberals think that underpriviledged black people should be saying. Everyone else is ignored - Nas being a prime example.

The thread title IS absurd, but no one would have looked in on it if I had just mentioned Nas. I had a point though: not so much that Nas is BETTER than Dylan (thats illogical because they do almost totally different things), but that Nas and other rappers lyric's are very good and extremely complex and intelligent, but are never recognised as such by most white rock and punk fans.

k-krack 09.10.2006 06:16 PM

I fail to see the intelligence or complexity in such words like
"O what a thrill inside a bitch feel
Gotta be strong and handle, it is real
Pussy killz
Mad shots keep a nigga open
Bitch have a nigga’s gun smoking
pussy killz"

seems to be leaning more towards the "sexist retard generic black rapper"

atari 2600 09.10.2006 06:17 PM

I just edited my last post to include this bolded part because I feared you would think that when I mentioned PE & I now see from your last post, ted, that you are all up-in-arms that I mentioned them.

I know you were just trying to educate us about some of the parallels of Nas' message to some of Dylan's more radical sentiments & like I wrote before, he is, from what I've read, more gifted of a rapper than most, but I still prefer Public Enemy for meaningful raps.
That may sound whitebread (since many white people also like PE) & dated to you, but it's my opinion.

By the way, Dylan can often be a cynical even hateful, untrusting, crotchety fuck in many of his songs.

atari 2600 09.10.2006 06:19 PM

Quote:

Originally Posted by k-krack
I fail to see the intelligence or complexity in such words like
"O what a thrill inside a bitch feel
Gotta be strong and handle, it is real
Pussy killz
Mad shots keep a nigga open
Bitch have a nigga’s gun smoking
pussy killz"

seems to be leaning more towards the "sexist retard generic black rapper"


Well, Robert Johnson & Led Zeppelin expressed it more poetically. Nas is decidely more literal.

porkmarras 09.10.2006 06:20 PM

Quote:

Originally Posted by ted_kennedy
That tops it all - the Public Enemy defense. People that know nothing about rap always say they like PE. Thats because they say things liberals think that underpriviledged black people should be saying. Everyone else is ignored - Nas being a prime example.

The thread title IS absurd, but no one would have looked in on it if I had just mentioned Nas. I had a point though: not so much that Nas is BETTER than Dylan (thats illogical because they do almost totally different things), but that Nas and other rappers lyric's are very good and extremely complex and intelligent, but are never recognised as such by most white rock and punk fans.

You're right there as in fact mysoginy is pointed out more when it comes to rappers than when it's an obvious feature in a white rock band's lyrics,sure.What do you do of the vile homophobia of certain rappers though?I'd be interested to hear.

ted_kennedy 09.10.2006 06:33 PM

Quote:

Originally Posted by k-krack
I fail to see the intelligence or complexity in such words like
"O what a thrill inside a bitch feel
Gotta be strong and handle, it is real
Pussy killz
Mad shots keep a nigga open
Bitch have a nigga’s gun smoking
pussy killz"

seems to be leaning more towards the "sexist retard generic black rapper"


WHAT IS THERE IN THOSE WORDS THAT IS MYSOGINIST?!

Read:

This man leans in, his boys laughing
Now I'm the spokesperson for Black men, this always happens
Says, "Since all Black women care about is who got dough
And all we do is call them either bitch or a Black hoe"
I say first brotha you ain't gotta be that cold
Since you ignorant, I'ma show you how the facts go
The biggest example in scandal of history
Were Monica Lewinksy or Donald Trump's pimping spree
Most woman who love Jeevanji of Gucci
Are pretentious non-Black groupies or floozies
But who are we to blame, not the dames
It's a man-made game, in essence our woman the same
Beautiful creatures, Black girls birthed the earth
So they deserve to earn man's purse
Matter fact, I'm about to go shopping with my dime

by NAS

You have to have a pretty racist worldview to automatically label someone as mysoginist because they are a black rapper.


ted_kennedy 09.10.2006 06:35 PM

But, yeah, one area where nas is at fault, like so many other rappers, is his homophobia. I can't wait for the day when I see a mainstream, authentic, talented rapper make a stand on the gay issue.

Edit: whoever it eventually is will have to be brave because it will amount to career suicide, sadly.

k-krack 09.10.2006 06:36 PM

Quote:

Originally Posted by ted_kennedy


You have to have a pretty racist worldview to automatically label someone as mysoginist because they are a black rapper.



no. i'm labeling his lyrics as mysoginist because of the mysoginistic content of the lyrics, wise guy.

Inhuman 09.10.2006 06:38 PM

Bob Dylan and NaS are competely uncomparable; however, the discussion of whether Nas' lyrics are considered "unintelligent" are completely mistaken. Do you make fun of Africans because most of them can't speak english? And because they can't speak english makes them unintelligent? His lyrics contain thousands of references that people don't understand unless they know what he's reffering to. Mad Lib? What's next Hayden? Mr. Lif?

I'm in complete support for NaS, he's an excellent rapper. I'd rep Ted for some of the points he made if he didn't make such a rediculous thread.

atari 2600 09.10.2006 06:39 PM

Eminem did it a bit with his duet with Elton John after he caught flack. I predict it's up his sleeve for when people start forgetting about him.

ted_kennedy did say that Dylan & Nas were ultimately incomparable himself.


my own trip, hardly anyone can handle this kind of truth:

John Lennon
Woman is the nigger of the world
Yes she is...think about it
Woman is the nigger of the world
Think about it...do something about it

We make her paint her face and dance
If she wont be a slave, we say that she dont love us
If shes real, we say shes trying to be a man
While putting her down, we pretend that shes above us

Woman is the nigger of the world...yes she is
If you dont believe me, take a look at the one youre with
Woman is the slave of the slaves
Ah, yeah...better scream about it

We make her bear and raise our children
And then we leave her flat for being a fat old mother hen
We tell her home is the only place she should be
Then we complain that shes too unworldly to be our friend

Woman is the nigger of the world...yes she is
If you dont believe me, take a look at the one youre with
Woman is the slave to the slaves
Yeah...alright...hit it!

We insult her every day on tv
And wonder why she has no guts or confidence
When shes young we kill her will to be free
While telling her not to be so smart we put her down for being so dumb

Woman is the nigger of the world
Yes she is...if you dont believe me, take a look at the one youre with
Woman is the slave to the slaves
Yes she is...if you believe me, you better scream about it

We make her paint her face and dance
We make her paint her face and dance
We make her paint her face and dance
We make her paint her face and dance
We make her paint her face and dance
We make her paint her face and dance

ted_kennedy 09.10.2006 06:41 PM

K, show me where, I fail to see.

k-krack 09.10.2006 06:42 PM

I just showed you.
"O what a thrill inside a bitch feel
Gotta be strong and handle, it is real
Pussy killz
Mad shots keep a nigga open
Bitch have a nigga’s gun smoking
pussy killz"

Glice 09.10.2006 06:44 PM

Here's ten pence: I prefer Nas to Dylan. I wouldn't describe myself as a head though. And that's the very first time I've seen someone mention the 'PE defence' on the internet, although I've heard it dozens of times in the (so-called) real world.

There is a dearth of people who appreciate mainstream hip-hop on this forum, I think that's an entirely valid point.

ted_kennedy 09.10.2006 06:47 PM

Quote:

Originally Posted by k-krack
I just showed you.
"O what a thrill inside a bitch feel
Gotta be strong and handle, it is real
Pussy killz
Mad shots keep a nigga open
Bitch have a nigga’s gun smoking
pussy killz"


It is a thrill, right?

HaydenAsche 09.10.2006 06:48 PM

You're saying that we are intolerant because we dislike music. If I don't like Boredoms does that mean I hate Asians?

Troll somewhere else, plz.

k-krack 09.10.2006 06:50 PM

sure is a thrill.
well put Asche.

ted_kennedy 09.10.2006 07:00 PM

No, I'm saying that YOU are racist and closed minded. I'm saying that most people on this board refuse to RECOGNISE that someone like Nas can be talented on their own terms.

What the fuck do you mean by troll? What is that?

HaydenAsche 09.10.2006 07:01 PM

Quote:

Originally Posted by ted_kennedy
No, I'm saying that YOU are racist and closed minded. I'm saying that most people on this board refuse to RECOGNISE that someone like Nas can be talented on their own terms.

What the fuck do you mean by troll? What is that?


But, I am not a racist. Calling someone a racist for not liking one particular black artist is the worst assumption one could make. You're a fucking moron.

ted_kennedy 09.10.2006 07:01 PM

And track, you have a pretty shady world view if you consider language like that mysoginist just because it comes from a black rapper. Its sad that you have to be hostile to me because I called you on it.

atari 2600 09.10.2006 07:01 PM

Well, at this point, you're either a troll, or you're a racist or both, ted.

At the very mention of PE, you flew off the handle when I had just written that from what I had read of Nas he was a "gifted rapper."
Nas is funny & also a truth-teller, even when the truth, as he understands it, isn't pretty. His wordplay is good, but so is the writing of a lot of rappers. He's no genius; he's much too gangsta to be a genius & I don't buy into the "art as a mirror of society" defence. He does it because it's a proven formula to be hard because it sells records.

Public Enemy felt that, as artists, they had a duty to not just reflect the world around them, but to be visionaries.

If you'll recall, I also wrote that some of Dylan's lyrics were cynical & even hateful & that he was often a crotchety, untrusting fuck so it isn't like he smells like roses 100% of the time either.

HaydenAsche 09.10.2006 07:04 PM

Quote:

Originally Posted by ted_kennedy
And track, you have a pretty shady world view if you consider language like that mysoginist just because it comes from a black rapper. Its sad that you have to be hostile to me because I called you on it.


Shady world view?

You have a terrible world view. You are like EyeballGrowth or SuchFriends. If not liking something moderately associated with african-americans makes someone a racist, then count me guilty. Count everyone guilty.


All times are GMT -5. The time now is 12:02 PM.

Powered by vBulletin Version 3.5.4
Copyright ©2000 - 2025, Jelsoft Enterprises Ltd.
All content ©2006 Sonic Youth