Sonic Youth Gossip

Sonic Youth Gossip (http://www.sonicyouth.com/gossip/index.php)
-   Sonic Gossip (http://www.sonicyouth.com/gossip/forumdisplay.php?f=3)
-   -   Goo #75 of Guitar World's 100 Greatest Albums (http://www.sonicyouth.com/gossip/showthread.php?t=4468)

kingcoffee 07.30.2006 08:00 PM

Quote:

Originally Posted by Cantankerous
integrity is meaningless and invalid.


WHy? How is it meanigless? Integrity is very meaningful. Sometimes, it's all we have. And how is it invalid?

Cantankerous 07.30.2006 08:17 PM

in the music industry, integrity doesn't mean shit.
Quote:

Originally Posted by kingcoffee
True, The Smiths may have formed a few years after U2 did, but they were much much more talented than them. Im not a big Smiths fan, but they are much better than U2.


that doesn't give you the right to make ridiculous claims saying that the edge is a derivative of johnny marr.

kingcoffee 07.30.2006 08:18 PM

Quote:

Originally Posted by Cantankerous
in the music industry, integrity doesn't mean shit.


Maybe not always, but a lot of people have been able to retain they'r integrity while living a rock and roll lifestyle. It just vanishes from most people, but those people never really had integrity to begin with.

Cantankerous 07.30.2006 08:21 PM

you're one of those ethically-absorbed "Fuck the man" people, aren't you?

kingcoffee 07.30.2006 08:23 PM

Kinda.

kingcoffee 07.30.2006 08:24 PM

Yeah.

kingcoffee 07.30.2006 08:24 PM

%100

HaydenAsche 07.30.2006 08:29 PM

Quote:

Originally Posted by Cantankerous
in the music industry, integrity doesn't mean shit.

that doesn't give you the right to make ridiculous claims saying that the edge is a derivative of johnny marr.


Your opinion is flawless.

Cantankerous 07.30.2006 08:55 PM

fuck the man!

kingcoffee 07.30.2006 09:03 PM

I never made the claim that The Edge was a derivative of The Smiths. I just said that anyone can make any claim that they want. I was merely supporting K-krak in his/her statement that the Edge sucks.

kingcoffee 07.30.2006 09:04 PM

Fuck em both.

Cantankerous 07.30.2006 09:22 PM

Quote:

Originally Posted by kingcoffee
I never made the claim that The Edge was a derivative of The Smiths. I just said that anyone can make any claim that they want. I was merely supporting K-krak in his/her statement that the Edge sucks.

like fuck you didn't:
Quote:

Originally Posted by kingcoffee
Don't be sorry. U2 are not a good band and you can give any credible, accurate criticism you like. The Edge is a derivative of Johnny Marr. They never should have gotten so big when much more engaging, talented artists were doomed to obscurity and financial ruin.


GeneticKiss 07.30.2006 09:25 PM

Quote:

Originally Posted by Cantankerous
U2 are terrible. PERIOD.

The Edge is not a derivative of Johnny Marr. U2 started before the Smiths.


Thank you for saying that.

U2 suck now. But in their prime (which has LONG since past), they had an original sound...sure they were mainstream (as if that's some sort of measure of how good a band is), but they were the exception, not the rule. Simple Minds and the Alarm mgith have thought they were in the same league, but they weren't.

If I someone bolted a set of headphones to my ears and forced me to listen to a U2 album over and over for the rest of my life, I'd rather it be The Joshua Tree.

Rob Instigator 07.31.2006 08:26 AM

fuck the man

crappydrummer 07.31.2006 03:54 PM

Quote:

Originally Posted by Magic Wheel Memory
Back in 1990, the same magazine named "Daydream Nation" the #16 guitar record of the 80's and called Thurston Moore one of four "guitarists who will matter in the 90's." I believe it was the writers, not the readers who came up with that. That was the first I ever heard of Sonic Youth, and that's what got me interested.

As for the new poll, had it been done by writers or critics, instead of readers, I suspect Daydream Nation would have been on there instead of Goo.


btw, i take 80's u2 records over any smiths or morrissey record anytime.
 

fluxequalsrad 07.31.2006 05:36 PM

wow what a group

fluxequalsrad 07.31.2006 05:36 PM

who the fuck is testament?

schizophrenicroom 07.31.2006 05:49 PM

and haha, 2 out of 4 ended up being important.

GeneticKiss 07.31.2006 05:59 PM

WINGER??!!

Ha, you can tell that was written before the 90s really started...


All times are GMT -5. The time now is 01:33 PM.

Powered by vBulletin Version 3.5.4
Copyright ©2000 - 2025, Jelsoft Enterprises Ltd.
All content ©2006 Sonic Youth